Optimal treatment for localized esophageal cancer still uncertain by JS Cooper, MD Guo, A Heskovic, et al., Chemoradiotherapy of Locally Advanced Esophageal Cancer: Long-term Follow-up of a Prospective Randomized Trial (RTOG-85-01), JAMA 1999;281:1623–7 DP Kelsen, R Ginsberg, TF Pajak, et al., Chemotherapy Followed by Surgery Compared With Surgery Alone for Localized Esophageal Cancer N Engl J Med 1998;339:1979–84

Abstract

These articles both report the results of multi-institutional, randomized, phase 3 trials for the treatment of patients with localized (T1-3 N0-1 M0) esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) or esophageal adenocarcinoma. Both studies were initiated and coordinated by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) but included patients enrolled by other study groups as well. Cooper et al. report late follow-up results for the RTOG 85-01 trial that was conducted between 1986 and 1990. This trial randomized patients to either radiation therapy (RT) alone (RT, 64 Gy in 32 fractions over 6.4 wk, n = 62) or combined RT and chemotherapy (50 Gy in 25 fractions over 5 wk, plus cisplatin 75 mg/m 2 i.v. on first day of wk 1, 5, 8, and 11, and continuous infusion fluorouracil (5FU) 1 g/m 2 per day on the first 4 days of the same weeks, n = 61). Most (82%) of the patients had SCC. Eight percent of the cohort randomly assigned to combined modality therapy experienced acute life-threatening toxic effects, and anadditional 2% died as a direct consequence of treatment. The randomized trial was halted in 1990 when an interim analysis found a highly significant difference in survival favoring the combined therapy group, after which 73 consecutive patients were enrolled into a nonrandomized study offering only the combined therapy regimen. At 5-yr of follow-up, the overall survival rate for the combined therapy group in the randomized study was 26% (95% CI, 15–37%) compared with 0% for RT alone. In the nonrandomized study, the 5-yr overall survival rate was 14% (95% CI, 6–23%). The histopathological type of tumor did not significantly influence survival. Cooper et al. now report that 22% of the randomized combined modality group survived at least 8 yr after treatment, and that there were no deaths caused by esophageal cancer after 5 yr post-treatment. The study reported by Kelsen et al. included 440 patients with esophageal adenocarcinoma (n = 236) or SCC (n = 204) randomized to either preoperative chemotherapy plus esophagectomy or to esophagectomy alone. The chemotherapy regimen consisted of three cycles of preoperative cisplatin and 5FU and two cycles after operation for responding patients. Doses were higher than those used in the RTOG 85-01 trial. Although radiation therapy was not part of the treatment plan, it could be given in some circumstances. There was no significant difference in median survival (14.9 months for chemotherapy plus surgery compared with 16.1 months for surgery alone), and there were also no significant differences in 1-yr, 2-yr, 3-yr, or disease-free survival rates. There were no significant differences in survival between patients with adenocarcinoma and those with SCC. A clinical response to chemotherapy, as assessed by barium contrast radiography, was found in 19% of patients who received chemotherapy. A complete pathological response was found in 2.5% of patients. There was no significant increase in operative complications in the chemotherapy treated group.