Optimal clipping intensity for balancing soil erosion control and runoff production on revegetated slopes

Abstract

Clipping management by reducing the above-ground parts of grassland has been gradually introduced to offset some of the additional issues caused by large-scale vegetation restoration, such as the formation of a dry soil layer, approaching the limits of watershed water resources, and reducing the sustainability of vegetation. Therefore, there is a scientific and practical need to evaluate the effectiveness of clipping management on runoff and erosion processes to ensure a balance between erosion control, surface water supply, and vegetation sustainability. In this study, simulated rainfall experiments with four levels of clipping intensities (no clipping, light clipping, heavy clipping, and clear clipping) were conducted to explore the mechanism of runoff and soil loss response under three rainfall intensities (i.e., 60, 90, and 120 mm·h−1) and three slope gradients (i.e., 18, 36, and 58 %) using structural equation modeling and variation partitioning. The results showed that the runoff depth increased by 42 %, 119 %, and 299 %, respectively, and the soil loss increased by 76 %, 80 %, and 470 %, respectively, in the light, heavy, and clear clipping treatments compared with the no clipping treatment, indicating that the increase in the percentage of runoff production and soil loss was not synchronized. According to the optimizing results of response surface method, the recommended vegetation cover after clipping was 23 % − 48 %, and the slope gradient of clipped vegetation should not exceed 36 %, which increased surface runoff while limiting soil erosion within an acceptable range. Runoff production and soil loss were primarily determined by rainfall intensity, followed by clipping intensity and slope gradient. Increasing rainfall intensity and slope gradient increased the effect of clipping on soil loss. Therefore, local rainfall and topography need to be considered in the application of clipping management. This study provides valuable insights into the use of clipping treatment as a sustainable management strategy for mitigating soil erosion and conserving surface water resources, and has important implications for developing restoration plans to promote sustainability in semi-arid ecosystems.