Open-trial response to antidepressant treatment in elderly patients with mixed depression and cognitive impairment

Abstract

We report open-trial antidepressant response in 16 inpatients with mixed symptoms of depression and cognitive impairment, compared to 16 elderly depressives without cognitive impairment. Criteria for adequate treatment specified a steady-state plasma nortriptyline level of 50–150 ng/ml for 4 consecutive weeks or a minimum of six treatments with electroconvulsive therapy. Ten of 16 mixed-symptom patients showed a drop in Hamilton depression ratings ⩾ 50% during treatment. Similarly, Blessed dementia ratings declined significantly; the % change in Blessed dementria ratings was significantly correlated with improvement in Hamilton depression ratings. By contrast, Folstein mini-mental state scores did not change significantly during treatment. Six of 16 (37.5%) patients showed resolution of cognitive impairment with adequate treatment of depression. Mixed-symptom patients diagnosed as suffering from major depression (with cognitive impairment) showed more robust pre-post treatment differences, particularly in Hamilton, Folstein, and Blessed dementia scores, than did mixed patients diagnosed as having primary degenerative dementia (with depression). In cognitively intact elderly depressives, the mean % change in Hamilton ratings was 72% (4.3), not significantly different from mean % change in mixed-symptom patients (57.4±29.9). The proportion of intact depressives showing a reduction ⩾ 50% in Hamilton depression ratings was significantly greater (93.8%) than in the mixed group (62.5%). In both groups, 81.3% of patients (13 of 16 in each cell) had a final Hamilton rating ⩽ 10. These data suggest that elderly patients with mixed depression and cognitive impairment respond to treatment similar to that used in cognitively intact elderly depressives. A controlled study of antidepressant treatment in mixed-symptom patients is warranted.