On thick and thin enamel in hominoids

Abstract

AbstractMartin (1983, 1985) reviewed the significance of enamel thickness in hominoid evolution. He studied cut faces of hominoid teeth using the scanning electron microscope and related enamel prism packing patterns to both enamel formation rates and enamel thickness, although he did not present primary data on formation rates, which he summarised as being either “fast” or “slow.” Martin concluded that thick enamel formed at a fast rate represented the ancestral condition in the human and great ape clade. Thin enamel in African apes reflected a secondary reduction in secretion rates, with outer enamel being formed at a slow rate. The present study on ground sections of great ape and human teeth, using polarised light microscopy, was designed to measure the spacing between incremental growth lines in enamel, including striae of Retzius and prism cross striations, to determine rates of enamel formation in hominoids. Measurements on stria spacing showed that striae generally diverged as they passed outwards through enamel in all taxa. Cross‐striation spacings also increased from inner to outer enamel. Secretion rates did not fall into two exclusive categories but varied, giving a spectrum of values generally increasing from within outwards at any one crown level and reducing in cervical enamel. There was no evidence for a reduction in enamel formation rates in outer enamel among African apes. These findings cast doubt on the proposition that the common ancestor of great apes and man had thick enamel formed at a fast rate. It is possible that thin enamel was the primitive condition, in which case thick enamel in humans and in Sivapithecus is derived, suggesting that thick enamel on low cusped teeth evolved on more than one occasion.