On the structure of subsets of the discrete cube with small edge boundary

  • Abstract
  • Highlights & Summary
  • PDF
  • Literature Map
  • Similar Papers
Abstract
Translate article icon Translate Article Star icon

On the structure of subsets of the discrete cube with small edge boundary, Discrete Analysis 2018:9, 29 pp. An isoperimetric inequality is a statement that tells us how small the boundary of a set can be given the of the set, for suitable notions of size and boundary. For example, one formulation of the classical isoperimetric inequality in $\mathbb R^n$ is as follows. Given a subset $X$ of $\mathbb R^n$, define the $\epsilon$-_expansion_ of $X$ to be the open set $X_\epsilon=\{y\in\mathbb R^n: d(y,X)<\epsilon\}$. If in addition $X$ is measurable, define the of its boundary to be $\lim\inf_{\epsilon\to 0} \epsilon^{-1}\mu(X_\epsilon\setminus X)$. (If $X$ is a set with a suitably smooth topological boundary $\partial X$, then this turns out to equal the surface measure of $\partial X$.) Then amongst all sets $X$ of a given measure, the one with the smallest boundary is an $n$-dimensional ball. Isoperimetric inequalities have been the focus of a great deal of research, partly for their intrinisic interest, but also because they have numerous applications. One particularly useful one is the _edge-isoperimetric inequality in the discrete cube_. This concerns subsets $X$ of the $n$-dimensional cube $\{0,1\}^n$, which we turn into a graph by joining two points $x$ and $y$ if they differ in exactly one coordinate. The of a set $X$ is simply its cardinality, the _edge-boundary_ of $X$ is defined to be the set of edges between $X$ and its complement, and the of the edge-boundary is the number of such edges. If $|X|=2^d$, then it is known that the edge-boundary is minimized when $X$ is a $d$-dimensional subspace of $\mathbb F_2^n$ generated by $d$ standard basis vectors. More generally, if $|X|=m$, then the edge-boundary is minimized when $X$ is an initial segment in the lexicographical ordering, which is the ordering where we set $x<y$ if $x_i<y_i$ for the first coordinate $i$ where $x_i$ and $y_i$ differ. (This coincides with the ordering we obtain if we think of the sequences as binary representations of integers.) For the two isoperimetric inequalities just mentioned, as well as many others, it is known that the extremal examples provided are essentially the only ones: a subset of $\mathbb R^n$ with a boundary that is as small as possible has to be an $n$-dimensional ball, and a subset of the discrete cube with edge-boundary that is as small as possible has to be an initial segment of the lexicographical ordering, up to the symmetries of the graph. Furthermore, there are _stablity_ results: a set with a boundary that is _almost_ as small as possible must be close to an extremal example. Such a result tells us that the isoperimetric inequalities are robust, in the sense that if you slightly perturb the condition on the set, then you only slightly perturb what the set has to look like. This paper is about an extremely precise stability result for the edge isoperimetric inequality in the discrete cube. There have been a number of papers on such results (see the introduction to the paper for details), but they have been mainly for sets of $2^d$ for some $d$, where the goal is to prove that they must be close to $d$-dimensional subcubes -- that is, subspaces (or their translates) generated by $d$ standard basis vectors. This paper considers sets of arbitrary and proves the following result. Suppose that $X$ is a subset of $\{0,1\}^n$ of $m$. Suppose that the of the edge-boundary of $X$ is at most $g_n(m)+l$, where $g_n(m)$ is the of the edge-boundary of the initial segment $I_m$ of $m$ in the lexicographical order. Then there is an automorphism $\phi$ of $\{0,1\}^n$ (meaning a bijection that takes neighbouring points to neighbouring points) such that $|X\Delta\phi(I_m)|\leq Cl$, where $C$ is an absolute constant. They give an example to show that $C$ must be at least 2, and thus that their result is best possible up to the value of the constant $C$. Previous proofs of stability versions of the edge-isoperimetric inequality in the cube have used Fourier analysis. The proof in this paper uses purely combinatorial methods, such as induction on the dimension, and compressions. To get these methods to work, several interesting ideas are needed, including some new results about the influence of variables.

Similar Papers
  • PDF Download Icon
  • Research Article
  • 10.19086/da.3699
On Isoperimetric Stability
  • Aug 6, 2018
  • Discrete Analysis
  • Vsevolod Lev

We show that a non-empty subset of an abelian group with a small edge boundary must be large; in particular, if $A$ and $S$ are finite, non-empty subsets of an abelian group such that $S$ is independent, and the edge boundary of $A$ with respect to $S$ does not exceed $(1-γ)|S||A|$ with a real $γ\in(0,1]$, then $|A| \ge 4^{(1-1/d)γ|S|}$, where $d$ is the smallest order of an element of $S$. Here the constant $4$ is best possible. As a corollary, we derive an upper bound for the size of the largest independent subset of the set of popular differences of a finite subset of an abelian group. For groups of exponent $2$ and $3$, our bound translates into a sharp estimate for the additive dimension of the popular difference set. We also prove, as an auxiliary result, the following estimate of possible independent interest: if $A \subset \mathbb Z^n$ is a finite, non-empty downset then, denoting by $w(a)$ the number of non-zero components of the vector $a\in A$, we have \[\frac1{|A|} \sum_{a\in A} w(a) \le \frac12\, \log_2 |A|.\]

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 172
  • 10.1214/aop/1024404285
An isoperimetric inequality on the discrete cube, and an elementary proof of the isoperimetric inequality in Gauss space
  • Jan 1, 1997
  • The Annals of Probability
  • S G Bobkov

We prove an isoperimetric inequality on the discrete cube which is the precise analog of a logarithmic inequality due to Talagrand. As a consequence, the Gaussian isoperimetric inequality is derived.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 8
  • 10.1016/j.jcta.2018.12.001
On a biased edge isoperimetric inequality for the discrete cube
  • Dec 7, 2018
  • Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series A
  • David Ellis + 2 more

On a biased edge isoperimetric inequality for the discrete cube

  • Book Chapter
  • 10.1007/978-3-031-19685-0_4
Ordering the Boolean Cube Vectors by Their Weights and with Minimal Change
  • Jan 1, 2022
  • Valentin Bakoev

The topic of generating all subsets of a given set occupies an important place in the books on combinatorial algorithms. The considered algorithms, like many other generating algorithms, are of two main types: for generating in lexicographic order or in Gray code order. Both use binary representation of integers (i.e., binary vectors) as characteristic vectors of the subsets.Ordering the vectors of the Boolean cube according to their weights is applied in solving some problems—for example, in computing the algebraic degree of Boolean functions, which is an important cryptographic parameter. Among the numerous orderings of Boolean cubic vectors by their (Hamming) weights, two are most important. The weight ordering, where the second criterion for sorting the vectors of equal weights, is the so-called weight-lexicographic order. It is considered in detail in [2]. Considered here is the second weight ordering, where the vectors of equal weights are arranged so that every two consecutive vectors differ in exactly two coordinates, i.e., they are ordered by minimal change. The properties of this ordering are derived. Based on these, an algorithm was developed that generates the vectors of the Boolean cube in this ordering. It uses a binary representation of integers and only performs additions of integers instead of operations on binary vectors. Its time and space complexities are of a linear type with respect to the number of vectors generated. The algorithm was used in the creation of sequence A351939 in OEIS [8].Keywordsn-dimensional Boolean cubeBinary vectorWeight ordering relationMinimal changeGenerating all subsetsGray codeRevolving door algorithm

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 43
  • 10.1093/imrn/rnv342
The Covering Radius of Randomly Distributed Points on a Manifold
  • Dec 17, 2015
  • International Mathematics Research Notices
  • A Reznikov + 1 more

We derive fundamental asymptotic results for the expected covering radius &lt;f&gt;$\\rho (X_N)$&lt;/f&gt; for &lt;f&gt;$N$&lt;/f&gt; points that are randomly and independently distributed with respect to surface measure on a sphere as well as on a class of smooth manifolds. For the unit sphere &lt;f&gt;$\\mathbb {S}^d \\subset \\mathbb {R}^{d+1}$&lt;/f&gt;, we obtain the precise asymptotic that &lt;f&gt;$\\mathbb {E}\\rho (X_N)[N/\\log N]^{1/d}$&lt;/f&gt; has limit &lt;f&gt;$[(d+1)\\upsilon _{d+1}/\\upsilon _d]^{1/d}$&lt;/f&gt; as &lt;f&gt;$N \\to \\infty $&lt;/f&gt;, where &lt;f&gt;$\\upsilon _d$&lt;/f&gt; is the volume of the &lt;f&gt;$d$&lt;/f&gt;-dimensional unit ball. This proves a recent conjecture of Brauchart et al. as well as extends a result previously known only for the circle. Likewise, we obtain precise asymptotics for the expected covering radius of &lt;f&gt;$N$&lt;/f&gt; points randomly distributed on a &lt;f&gt;$d$&lt;/f&gt;-dimensional ball, a &lt;f&gt;$d$&lt;/f&gt;-dimensional cube, as well as on a three-dimensional polyhedron (where the points are independently distributed with respect to volume measure). More generally, we deduce upper and lower bounds for the expected covering radius of &lt;f&gt;$N$&lt;/f&gt; points that are randomly and independently distributed on a compact metric measure space, provided the measure satisfies certain regularity assumptions.

  • PDF Download Icon
  • Research Article
  • 10.37236/12043
Reflect-Push Methods Part I: Two Dimensional Techniques
  • Mar 8, 2024
  • The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics
  • Nikola Kuzmanovski + 1 more

We determine all maximum weight downsets in the product of two chains, where the weight function is a strictly increasing function of the rank. Many discrete isoperimetric problems can be reduced to the maximum weight downset problem. Our results generalize Lindsay's edge-isoperimetric theorem in two dimensions in several directions. They also imply and strengthen (in several directions) a result of Ahlswede and Katona concerning graphs with maximal number of adjacent pairs of edges. We find all optimal shifted graphs in the Ahlswede-Katona problem. Furthermore, the results of Ahlswede-Katona are extended to posets with a rank increasing and rank constant weight function. Our results also strengthen a special case of a recent result by Keough and Radcliffe concerning graphs with the fewest matchings. All of these results are achieved by applications of a key lemma that we call the reflect-push method. This method is geometric and combinatorial. Most of the literature on edge-isoperimetric inequalities focuses on finding a solution, and there are no general methods for finding all possible solutions. Our results give a general approach for finding all compressed solutions for the above edge-isoperimetric problems.&#x0D; By using the Ahlswede-Cai local-global principle, one can conclude that lexicographic solutions are optimal for many cases of higher dimensional isoperimetric problems. With this and our two dimensional results we can prove Lindsay's edge-isoperimetric inequality in any dimension. Furthermore, our results show that lexicographic solutions are the unique solutions for which compression techniques can be applied in this general setting.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 4
  • 10.1007/bf02772990
A finite-dimensional normed space with two non-equivalent symmetric bases
  • Feb 1, 1994
  • Israel Journal of Mathematics
  • W T Gowers

A sequence of finite-dimensional normed spaces is constructed, each with two symmetric bases, such that the sequence of equivalence constants between these bases is unbounded. An essential tool in the proof is the edge-isoperimetric inequality in the discrete cube.

  • PDF Download Icon
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 2
  • 10.37236/9860
An Isoperimetric Inequality for Hamming Balls and Local Expansion in Hypercubes
  • Jan 28, 2022
  • The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics
  • Zilin Jiang + 1 more

We prove a vertex isoperimetric inequality for the $n$-dimensional Hamming ball $\mathcal{B}_n(R)$ of radius $R$. The isoperimetric inequality is sharp up to a constant factor for sets that are comparable to $\mathcal{B}_n(R)$ in size. A key step in the proof is a local expansion phenomenon in hypercubes.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 2
  • 10.1016/j.ejc.2017.12.003
An isoperimetric inequality for antipodal subsets of the discrete cube
  • Jan 12, 2018
  • European Journal of Combinatorics
  • David Ellis + 1 more

An isoperimetric inequality for antipodal subsets of the discrete cube

  • Research Article
  • 10.18255/1818-1015-2024-3-316-337
Estimation of interpolation projectors using Legendre polynomials
  • Sep 13, 2024
  • Modeling and Analysis of Information Systems
  • Mikhail V Nevskii

We give some estimates for the minimum projector norm under linear interpolation on a compact set in ${\mathbb R}^n$. Let $\Pi_1({\mathbb R}^n)$ be the space of polynomials in $n$ variables of degree at most $1$, $\Omega$ is a compactum in ${\mathbb R}^n$, $K={\rm conv}(\Omega)$. We will assume that ${\rm vol}(K)&gt;0$. Let the points $x^{(j)}\in \Omega$, $1\leq j\leq n+1,$ be the vertices of an $n$-dimensional nondegenerate simplex. The interpolation projector $P:C(\Omega)\to \Pi_1({\mathbb R}^n)$ with the nodes $x^{(j)}$ is defined by the equations $Pf\left(x^{(j)}\right)=f\left(x^{(j)}\right)$. By $\|P\|_\Omega$ we mean the norm of $P$ as an operator from $C(\Omega)$ to $C(\Omega)$. By $\theta_n(\Omega)$ we denote the minimal norm $\|P\|_\Omega$ of all operators $P$ with nodes belonging to $\Omega$. By ${\rm simp}(E)$ we denote the maximal volume of the simplex with vertices in $E$. We establish the inequalities $\chi_n^{-1}\left(\frac{{\rm vol}(K)}{{\rm simp}(\Omega)}\right)\leq \theta_n(\Omega)\leq n+1.$ Here $\chi_n$ is the standardized Legendre polynomial of degree $n$. The lower estimate is proved using the obtained characterization of Legendre polynomials through the volumes of convex polyhedra. More specifically, we show that for every $\gamma\ge 1$ the volume of the set $\left\{x=(x_1,...,x_n)\in{\mathbb R}^n : \sum |x_j| +\left|1- \sum x_j\right|\le\gamma\right\}$ is equal to ${\chi_n(\gamma)}/{n!}$. In the case when $\Omega$ is an $n$-dimensional cube or an $n$-dimensional ball, the lower estimate gives the possibility to obtain the inequalities of the form $\theta_n(\Omega)\geqslant c\sqrt{n}$. Also we formulate some open questions.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 16
  • 10.1017/s0963548310000234
On the Influences of Variables on Boolean Functions in Product Spaces
  • Jul 9, 2010
  • Combinatorics, Probability and Computing
  • Nathan Keller

In this paper we consider the influences of variables on Boolean functions in general product spaces. Unlike the case of functions on the discrete cube, where there is a clear definition of influence, in the general case several definitions have been presented in different papers. We propose a family of definitions for the influence that contains all the known definitions, as well as other natural definitions, as special cases. We show that the proofs of the BKKKL theorem and of other results can be adapted to our new definition. The adaptation leads to generalizations of these theorems, which are tight in terms of the definition of influence used in the assertion.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 29
  • 10.4310/jdg/1645207496
Alexandrov-Fenchel inequalities for convex hypersurfaces with free boundary in a ball
  • Feb 1, 2022
  • Journal of Differential Geometry
  • Julian Scheuer + 2 more

In this paper we first introduce quermassintegrals for free boundary hypersurfaces in the &#13;\n(&#13;\nn&#13;\n+&#13;\n1&#13;\n)&#13;\n-dimensional Euclidean unit ball. Then we solve some related isoperimetric type problems for convex free boundary hypersurfaces, which lead to new Alexandrov–Fenchel inequalities. In particular, for &#13;\nn&#13;\n=&#13;\n2&#13;\n we obtain a Minkowski-type inequality and for &#13;\nn&#13;\n=&#13;\n3&#13;\n we obtain an optimal Willmore-type inequality. To prove these estimates, we employ a specifically designed locally constrained inverse harmonic mean curvature flow with free boundary.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 9
  • 10.1006/inco.2001.3087
Online Variable Sized Covering
  • Dec 1, 2001
  • Information and Computation
  • Leah Epstein

Online Variable Sized Covering

  • Book Chapter
  • Cite Count Icon 12
  • 10.1007/3-540-51517-8_136
Complexity of standard bases in projective dimension zero
  • Jan 1, 1989
  • Marc Giusti

This paper is the continuation of a previous one devoted to the complexity of standard bases in projective dimension zero (see Giusti, 1989). We improve the upper bound on the maximal degree of elements in a standard basis, with respect to any choice of coordinates and any compatible ordering, given in loc.cit. This bound is sharp, being attained for complete intersections and lexicographic ordering.

  • Book Chapter
  • Cite Count Icon 6
  • 10.1007/3-540-54195-0_61
Complexity of standard bases in projective dimension zero II
  • Jan 1, 1991
  • Marc Giusti

This paper is the continuation of a previous one devoted to the complexity of standard bases in projective dimension zero (see Giusti, 1989). We improve the upper bound on the maximal degree of elements in a standard basis, with respect to any choice of coordinates and any compatible ordering, given in loc.cit. This bound is sharp, being attained for complete intersections and lexicographic ordering.

Save Icon
Up Arrow
Open/Close
Setting-up Chat
Loading Interface