On the reliability of 12 high-resolution precipitation products for process-based hydrological modeling in China

Abstract

Numerous satellite- and gauge-based precipitation products (SBPs/GBPs) have emerged in recent decades, providing unprecedented opportunities for process-based hydrological modeling. However, their reliability in high-resolution hydrological modeling at continental scales, especially for variables other than streamflow, remains to be investigated. Factors influencing their hydrological performance (e.g., catchment sizes, precipitation products’ spatial resolution and raw observation information) are also under debate. Here, we provide a comprehensive analysis of the hydrological reliability of 12 state-of-the-art precipitation datasets over China using a process-based land surface model at 0.125° resolution. Simulations driven by different precipitation products are evaluated across ∼ 200 basins with different catchment sizes. Results show that all simulations well reproduce the streamflow, soil moisture, evapotranspiration, and snow-depth at monthly timescale. None of the precipitation products provides best results for all variables, but the gauge-based and infrared-microwave-merged satellite products are superior to the infrared satellite products. The gauge-based regional precipitation product based on the 0.25° China precipitation dataset and the 6-km China Land Data Assimilation System (CN051_CLDAS) provides the best performance generally, followed by two global precipitation products from the Global Precipitation Climatology Centre (GPCC V2022) and the Global Precipitation Measurement Integrated Multi-satellite Retrievals (IMERGE-F V6). However, the advantages of CLDAS_CN051 and GPCC V2022 against satellite-based precipitation products are scale-dependent and tend to disappear over large-scale catchments (>106 km2). The spatial resolutions of precipitation products show no relationship with their hydrological performance, but the number of stations used to generate/bias-correct the precipitation is positively correlated with the performance of streamflow and soil moisture simulations. Differences among the climatology of terrestrial water-cycle components caused by using different precipitation products are notable and tend to increase over the dry and cold regions. Snow depth is the variable most sensitive to precipitation datasets, followed by runoff, ET, and soil moisture. This study suggests that using more station observations is more important than increasing spatial resolutions to enhance the applications of precipitation products in high-resolution hydrological modeling.