On the Rayleigh–Bénard problem: dominant compressibility effects

Abstract

We study the linear temporal hydrodynamic stability in the Rayleigh–Bénard problem for a compressible fluid (a perfect gas) under marginally super-adiabatic conditions, i.e. when the ambient temperature gradient only slightly exceeds the adiabatic gradient and then only within the fluid adjacent to the upper (cold) wall. The onset of convection in this limit demonstrates some unique features which differ qualitatively from those of the familiar Boussinesq approximation. Thus, the ensuing convection is effectively confined to a narrow domain of the fluid close to the upper wall and is characterized by large wavenumbers. Furthermore, these distinct attributes persist with diminishing temperature difference, implying that the prevailing generalized Boussinesq approximation (based on the use of the potential temperature gradient) is non-uniform in the present limit. This non-uniformity is resolved in terms of the small yet significant variations of fluid properties (which are commonly neglected). We comment on the analogy between the present problem and the Taylor–Couette problem for a viscous incompressible fluid within a narrow gap between counter-rotating cylinders. We briefly discuss the potential relevance of the present limit to some recent observations of the onset of convection within near-critical fluids.