On the origin of Caimaninae: insights from new fossils of Tsoabichi greenriverensis and a review of the evidence

Abstract

ABSTRACT An incomplete fossil record and unstable phylogenies of extinct taxa hamper reconstructing the early evolution of Caimaninae. We describe previously unpublished articulated fossils of a key species, Tsoabichi greenriverensis from the early Eocene Green River Formation of North America, exhibiting further character evidence for the caimanine affinities of this taxon. Parsimony analysis of modified morphological taxon-character datasets coupled with a critical review of character evolution and published phylogenies reveals that fossil evidence for Palaeogene crown group and Late Cretaceous total-group representatives is unreliable due to uncertain character evolution in early Alligatoridae. The earliest unambiguous fossil age for total and crown-group Caimaninae are 63.5 Ma and 18.06 Ma, respectively. These calibration points follow best practices and are vital for better constrained estimates of time calibrated analyses. Phylogeny continues to imply two separate Caimaninae dispersals between North and South America, but instead of a northward back-dispersal, we find two Palaeogene dispersals to South America an equally likely hypothesis. Miocene taxa of Central America previously assigned to the stem lineage ancestral to South American Caimaninae are reinterpreted as part of a Neogene northward expansion of the crown group.