On the neutral curve of the flat-plate boundary layer: comparison between experiment, Orr–Sommerfeld theory and asymptotic theory

Abstract

The neutral stability curve for the flat-plate boundary layer has been calculated using the Orr–Sommerfeld equation and compared to those obtained using upper- and lower-branch scalings. The Orr–Sommerfeld results agree well with the lower-branch scaling at Reynolds numbers relevant to experiment, but agree well with the upper-branch scaling only for Rδ > 105. It is shown that the critical layer only emerges from the viscous wall layer when Rδ > 105. This suggests that for Rδ < 105, when the critical layer lies within the viscous wall layer, the disturbance has a triple-deck structure, even for the upper branch of the neutral curve (which can be reached if the phase jump across the critical layer is retained).The transition from a triple-deck to a five-deck structure with increasing Reynolds number on the upper branch occurs relatively abruptly and can be associated with a square-root branch point in the Tietjens function. Essentially, the lower- and upper-branch scalings pertain to two different modes, the first possessing a triple-deck structure, the second a five-deck structure. The modes are connected at the branch point, and the neutral curves of each mode join to give a single curve close to this branch point. The asymptotic expansions for the upper- and lower-branch neutral curves depend upon the analyticity of the dispersion relationship, and so the proximity of the branch point indicates where these expansions will be liable to inaccuracies. This explains the poor neutral-curve predictions made by five-deck analyses at the Reynolds numbers where transition occurs.