On the influence of the mean-free-path parameter on intranuclear cascade calculations

Abstract

In a recent letter GINOCCHIO and BLANN (2) compared results of intranuclear cascade model (ICM) calculations obtained either with a nucleon mean-free-path (mfp) in nuclear matter corresponding to free 3~-2C scattering cross-sections, or with a four times longer mfp. The latter assumption was reported to give far poorer agreement with the experimental data; and this conclusion was reported as evidence in favour of the use of the shorter mfp values in pre-equilibrium decay models, whose alternate formulations have been lately discussed at some length (2.6). We maintain tha t ICI~[ calculations performed with the free ~ ~ scatter mfp in general do not afford an accurate reproduction of the excitation functions of reactions induced by protons of some tens of MeV, and of the energy integrated spectra of the emitted particles. In fact, published results of ICM calculations have shown a systematic tendency to underestimate the emission of high-energy particles, and to overestimate compound-nucleus production. We made this statement, which agrees with an opinion already expressed by MILLER (D, on the basis of the findings of several works cited in ref. (2). Our belief is further supported by other results of BERTINI et al. (S) (e l . Specifically fig. 4 thereof), and even by the figures reported by the authors of ref. (1). However, in spite of such inadequacies of the ICM calculations, the model seems to retain a good measure of appeal as an intui t ive tool much in use for practical purposes.