On the Effectiveness of Ransomware Decryption Tools

Abstract

Ransomware is a type of malware that locks out its victim’s access to their devices or data – typically by encrypting files – and demands payment in exchange of restoring access. To fight the increasing threat posed by ransomware, security researchers and practitioners have developed decryption tools. These aim to help victims in recovering their data, generally by decrypting the compromised files without paying the ransom. Unfortunately, there has been minimal research on the effectiveness of decryption and recovery tools. There is a scant understanding regarding the extent to which these tools can actually recover compromised data. The research presented in this work aims to cover this gap by providing an empirical study on these tools’ effectiveness – in terms of decrypting and restoring compromised data. For doing so, we tested a total of 78 tools created by 11 security companies against 61 ransomware samples. That allows us to present an in-depth critical discussion of the real effectiveness of the recovery tools studied. We found that nearly half of the tools fail to satisfactorily recover compromised data. We conclude that there is still a lot of work to be done before these tools can make a real positive impact on ransomware victims. We finish our work by offering some additional insights and recommendations that could help in improving the effectiveness of ransomware decryption tools.