On the consistency of the Oppenheimer-Snyder solution for a dust star. Reply to Marshall’s criticism

Abstract

The recent alternative to the Oppenheimer-Snyder (OS) solution for a dust star proposed by Marshall in the paper “Gravitational collapse without black holes” (Astrophys. Space Sci. 342:329, 2012) is analyzed. It is shown that this proposal leads to a non-diagonal metric, with which the Einstein equations become practically unsolvable. Any ansatz proposed as their exact solution turns out to be arbitrary and may be unlimited number of the such solutions. This is due to the fact that an auxiliary function $y(R,r)$ , introduced by OS as $t=M(y)$ , is unambiguously fixed by the diagonality condition and the matching on the surface, and thus in the non-diagonal case it remains arbitrary. It is also shown that the OS solution, as a description in terms of the Schwarzschild coordinates, leads to a frozen star (or frozar) picture not only for the surface, asymptotically freezing outside the gravitational radius, but for interior layers too which also freeze near their own asymptotes. At most of the inner region these asymptotes are located almost equidistantly and only for layers initially close to the surface they become denser. The reason for the such densifying is not “a gravitational repulsion”, but their later freezing and higher spatial contractions, while they remain be uniform and free falling in the comoving frames.