On negation in Hilog

Abstract

The logic HiLog of Chen, Kifer, and Warren has a second order syntax, while its semantics is first order. HiLog programs with negative literals in the body are considered. A stable-model semantics and a well-founded semantics for this class of program are defined, and it is shown that these semantics generalize the stable-model semantics and the well-founded semantics, respectively, for range-restricted normal programs. A second order property called preservation under extensions is proposed and investigated. Preservation under extensions ensures that the semantics of a program is not changed when rules having no symbols in common with the program are appended to the program. It is shown that for normal programs, domain independence and preservation under extensions are equivalent, while for HiLog programs, preservation under extensions is strictly stronger. Range restrictedness is generalized to HiLog programs in two ways, and it is shown that range restricted HiLog programs are preserved under extensions with respect to the well-founded semantics. Conditions under which the well-founded semantics is two-valued are investigated, and the class of modularly stratified programs is generalized to HiLog. An extension of magic-set techniques to modularly stratified HiLog programs is described.