Observed Non–Steady State Cooling and the Moderate Cluster Cooling Flow Model

Abstract

We examine recent developments in the cluster cooling flow scenario following recent observations by Chandra and XMM-Newton. We show that the distribution of gas emissivity verses temperature determined by XMM-Newton gratings observations demonstrates that the central gas in cooling flow clusters cannot be in simple steady-state. Combining this result with the lack of spectroscopic evidence for gas below one-third of the ambient cluster temperature is strong evidence that the gas is heated intermittently. While the old steady-state isobaric cooling flow model is incompatible with recent observations, a cooling flow in which the gas undergoes intermittent heating that effectively reduces the age of a cooling flow is consistent with observations. Most of the gas within cooling flows resides in the hottest gas, which is prevented from cooling continuously and attaining a steady-state configuration. This results in a mass cooling rate that decreases with decreasing temperature, with a much lower mass cooling rate at the lowest temperatures. The present paper strengthens the moderate cooling flow model, which can accommodate the unique activities observed in cooling flow clusters.