Observations on the determination of protein quality by the Thomas–Mitchell method

Abstract

AbstractIn the Thomas–Mitchell method for the assessment of protein quality, metabolic faecal nitrogen (MFN) and endogenous urinary nitrogen (EUN) are used to adjust faecal and urinary N excretion on test diets so that true digestibility (TD) and biological value (BV) can be calculated. Using an experimental technique where the urine and faeces from young growing rats were collected every 2 days for an experimental period of 28 days, trends in the estimation of MFN and in the determination of TD and BV were examined. A diet containing 20 g egg albumen kg−1 on an as fed basis (2.85 g N kg−1 dry matter) has previously been found to be most applicable for the estimation of EUN. This diet was also found to be appropriate for the estimation of MFN. To examine the effect of a change from an ad libitum intake of a stock diet (containing 150 g protein kg−1) to the restricted intake of a test diet (containing 80–100 g protein kg−1) on the determination of TD and BV, three protein sources (egg albumen, casein+1% L‐methionine and soya bean meal) were fed at two levels of intake: 9 and 15 g day−1. The time taken for the faecal N excretion to stablilise was very similar with all diets at both levels of intake. The TD of all three protein sources at both levels of intake increased gradually with increasing lengths of preliminary period. However, this increase was not great, and had little effect on the determination of the BV. Stabilisation of urinary N excretion with the three diets depended on the quality of the protein and the amount fed. This led to variation in BV with lengthening preliminary periods, especially at the lower level of intake. Urinary N excretion, and consequently BV, stabilised most rapidly with the highest quality protein (egg albumen) at the highest level of intake. However, stabilisation of BV with the lowest quality protein (soya bean meal) did not occur until after a preliminary period of 12 days, even at 15 g day−1. This preliminary period is considerably longer than that usually employed, and thus it appears that for many proteins the BV may have been assessed during a period before N retention has fully stabilised.