Observation of Charge-Dependent Azimuthal Correlations in p-Pb Collisions and Its Implication for the Search for the Chiral Magnetic Effect.

V Khachatryan,R Radogna,J Chu,A Aubin,S Ganjour,M Ahmad,M Konecki,A Purohit,T Dorigo,N Sahoo,D Nash,G Bolla,M Herndon,S Nahn,S Obraztsov,G Smith,A Borzou,M Mittal,I Korol,F Santanastasio,R Sacchi,M Sani,A Morelos Pineda,C Hill,M Choi,J Veverka,N Tosi,A Di Francesco,A Kornmayer,C Delaere,E Migliore,W Lange,J Kieseler,J Freeman,A Ghezzi,L Sonnenschein,C Mclean,Y Kim,I.-A Melzer-Pellmann,S Salva,J Alcaraz Maestre,I Heredia-De La Cruz,H Li,V Candelise,Z Chen,D Krofcheck,S Grünendahl,B Jayatilaka,Y Musienko,V Epshteyn,G Bagliesi,S Gennai,J Hardenbrook,V Popov,A Gilbert,M Xiao,J Mejia Guisao,X Niu,M Delcourt,D Denegri,S Rahatlou,P Lecoq,P Vitulo,D Cussans,M Carver,E Avdeeva,A Yagil,G Iaselli,C Diez Pardos,P Chang,P Checchia,O Kara,N Amin,M Hildreth,M Mooney,B Stieger,C Zorbilmez,E Vlasov,M Buttignol,Z Mao,V Kumar,J Alexander,J Zabel,S Moortgat,J Lee,J Almond,A Baty,J Hirschauer,R Syarif,D Petyt,P Vanlaer,A Bocci,D Olivito,G Codispoti,V Knünz,S Stoykova,R Stone,L Wendland,T Weiler,K Lamichhane,T Adams,M Mohammadi Najafabadi,A Makovec,E Eren,K Romanowska-Rybinska,A Pérez-Calero Yzquierdo,T Aziz,A Safonov,T Peiffer,D Sunar Cerci,V Mossolov,N Akchurin,R Arcidiacono,L Quertenmont,P Salvini,M Vidal Marono,A Schmidt,M Sharan,M Maity,M Verzetti,K Mazumdar,O Behnke,E Focardi,U Kiminsu,F Rezaei Hosseinabadi,S Boren,A Baskakov,G Apollinari,L Dodd,T Lindén,L Moreels,M Hoffmann,P De Castro Manzano,D D’Enterria,J Piedra Gomez,J Buchanan,D Moran,B Penning,L Apanasevich,G Krintiras,P Mcbride,C Welke,E Auffray,S Kesisoglou,R Caspart,V Korotkikh,X Shi,P Merkel,T Roy,H Zhang,M Hamer,P Silva,T Bergauer,D Eckstein,R D’Alessandro,D Duchardt,M Cepeda,D Abercrombie,J Hammer,J Wang,K Rose,U Langenegger,E Halkiadakis,M Yang,M Vazquez Acosta,S Ragazzi,Y Jo,A Johnson,S Girgis,Y Chao,P Verwilligen,M Pierini,A Messineo,A Tsirou,D Acosta,D Krücker,A Saddique,E Navarro De Martino,N Nishu,N Pastika,J Tao,Y.-J Lee,G Hanson,S Bianco,A Kubik,R Hirosky,M Maggi,E Berry,A Pompili,M Shoaib,T Esch,D Tlisov,N Woods,B Casal,J Berger,S Dugad,S Kyriacou,M Vander Donckt,D Menasce,A Tumasyan,J Bendavid,A Raspereza,T Camporesi,M Quittnat,T Kress,D Lange,X Coubez,F Raupach,I Evangelou,G Riley,S Spanier,J Mousa,R Bartek,E De La Cruz-Burelo,D Dobur,J Fay,D Elumakhov,I Vardanyan,Y Gershtein,T Ferbel,J Varela,S Orfanelli,S Das,A Perieanu,K Harder,B Liu,V Sordini,J Talvitie,M Cuffiani,F Vazquez Valencia,C You,D Shtol,D Liko,A Petrilli,D Wright,A Lelek,R Granier De Cassagnac,O Kodolova,G Nicolas Kaufman,M Arneodo,Z Tsamalaidze,B Francois,B Dorney,P Lariccia,S Brandt,A Leonidov,A Rose,S Dasu,H Tholen,C Schnaible,A Avetisyan,D Green,P Schleper,C Lange,S Gundacker,L Mastrolorenzo,C Cowden,J Castle,H Qu,C Newman-Holmes,R Sharma,M Preuten,A Ovcharova,M Margoni,R Yonamine,C Seitz,T Cornelis,S Chauhan,Y Wu,C Scharf,N Magini,G Dolinska,W Ko,R Yohay,W Busza,W De Boer,G De Nardo,A Lanaro,A Soha,A Roy,S Schumann,R Bellan,V Hegde,W Adam,W Xie,P Mal,T Frueboes,M Komm,S Morovic,J Hegeman,N Krasnikov,A Heister,R Chudasama,G Dissertori,P Kurt,B Grynyov,M Murray,E Carrera Jarrin,P Kokkas,R Bhandari,X Janssen,L Cadamuro,D Colling,K Rabbertz,C Maguire,N De Filippis,C Dietz,Sa Jain,L Gauthier,N Leonardo,C Heidemann,A Santocchia,G Iles,S Shmatov,G Davies,K Burkett,J Dittmann,J Sturdy,J Goh,A Bhardwaj,A Staiano,J Nachtman,I Suárez Andrés,M Dobson,M Misiura,S Sekmen,R Venditti,S My,L Thomas,L Sudic,P De Barbaro,C Beirão Da Cruz E Silva,I Pedraza,M Lo Vetere,C Schwick,A Rane,D Bisello,M Khakzad,X Sun,M Brodski,M Van De Klundert,M Konyushikhin,B Bilki,I Khvastunov,A Dierlamm,G Kole,N Loukas,I Anderson,G Polese,R Chierici,R Teixeira De Lima,A Bean,S Kalafut,I Glushkov,F Jensen,T Ruggles,M Barrio Luna,A Triossi,A Belyaev,O Evdokimov,M Marionneau,S Durgut,A Rizzi,J Kunkle,P Bunin,J Heideman,G Rakness,R Vilar Cortabitarte,S Malhotra,G Ortona,C Snyder,T Rovelli,V Azzolini,A Bundock,F Ravera,D Duggan,A Reinsvold,S Piperov,S Kaplan,F Wang,R Goldouzian,A Zhokin,Sh Jain,J Sun,C Hartl,N Saoulidou,I Krätschmer,S Wimpenny,D Lincoln,A Zuranski,V Valuev,G Auzinger,A Castro,P Traczyk,P Lecomte,A Campbell,R Leonardi,J Lim,W Fang,D Rank,P Pigard,R Klanner,M Kadastik,F Palla,S Ahuja,Y Ban,B Asavapibhop,T Kamon,N Ruckstuhl,R Kogler,A Levin,R Potenza,S Beranek,J Luo,A De Roeck,A Giammanco,C Brew,G Quast,P Govoni,S Oliveros,C Lourenço,B Allen,M Masciovecchio,M Derdzinski,N Lychkovskaya,J Duarte,M Donegà,F Ligabue,I Vila,L Benato,T Tabarelli De Fatis,I Macneill,F Meier,O Prokofyev,F Preiato,J Faulkner,L Pacher,A Givernaud,L Finco,S Spannagel,M Gallinaro,K Burt,D Burton,C Vernieri,R Rusack,B Clerbaux,C George,J Garay Garcia,D Konstantinov,S Linn,H Ni,E Bouvier,M Tosi,L Uplegger,J Brandstetter,A Poll,B Kreis,A Gurrola,S Braibant-Giacomelli,F De Guio,T Dreyer,A Kaur,B Parida,A Ledovskoy,L Scodellaro,I Volobouev,D Roy,A Kalogeropoulos,A Terkulov,K Mei,S Knutzen,Z Hu,A Dermenev,R Bhattacharya,K Lassila-Perini,F Beaudette,S Casasso,D Salerno,O Pooth,A Montanari,J Zhang,G Fedi,P Paolucci,S Liu,S Costa,B Marzocchi,M Verweij,R Eusebi,R Bi,S Tkaczyk,J Dolen,P Gunnellini,D Hits,S Nuzzo,N Skhirtladze,J Conway,K Shchelina,A Baden,V Palichik,R Kamalieddin,S Maruyama,A Snigirev,L Cristella,I Bayshev,P Dunne,D Rabady,C Galloni,D Loukas,U Joshi,H Rykaczewski,B Fabbro,I Gorbunov,S Paramesvaran,W.-S Hou,M Rossini,C Collard,D Bonacorsi,L Gouskos,V Zykunov,B Lee,A Moeller,J Ellison,D Troendle,A Zabi,A Godshalk,M Menichelli,E Olaiya,C Fangmeier,P Azzurri,S Kudella,S Baffioni,V Kim,A Ruiz-Jimeno,S Bitioukov,U Behrens,C West,R Ryutin,H Behnamian,M Spiropulu,V Andreev,A Güth,B Boimska,F Giordano,G Funk,E Palencia Cortezon,E Tarkovskii,O Karacheban,C Ferraioli,B Gomber,P Capiluppi,F Ptochos,D Wood,N Demaria,T Järvinen,C Wöhrmann,R Kinnunen,D Vannerom,V Zhukova,V Golovtsov,S Brochet,R Ulrich,A Santoro,D Sheffield,A Bodek,D Noonan,G Bencze,E Usai,M Zeyrek,M Walczak,O Bouhali,M Pieri,N Daci,D Berry,R Wolf,R Kumar,T Rohe,A Kyriakis,D Ciangottini,H Brun,J Turkewitz,A Saha,H Delannoy,N Tyurin,M Raidal,A Uzunian,E Salama,A Albert,C Beluffi,V Innocente,M Tadel,S Dildick,G Flouris,N Mucia,T Matsushita,M Szleper,J Rander,A.-M Magnan,C De Oliveira Martins,M Schröder,P Avery,D Teyssier,P Iaydjiev,D Gonzalez,D Arcaro,A Karneyeu,R Chawla,N Voytishin,G Flügge,S Cho,M Sun,M Dünser,S Dutt,S Cittolin,A Gude,E Conte,Y Ivanov,T Chwalek,M Nguyen,M Voutilainen,V O’Dell,B Safarzadeh,C Palmer,D Barney,V Cherepanov,F Fabozzi,T Lenzi,V Gavrilov,S Malvezzi,O Hindrichs,Y Skovpen,M Machet,C Rovelli,Y Yilmaz,J Strauss,L Levchuk,A Kalinowski,L Mirabito,U Husemann,N Mirman,I Kravchenko,M Planer,L Kreczko,A Jafari,N Bacchetta,M Aldaya Martin,C Botta,V Smirnov,A Gozzelino,Y Go,M Osherson,I Ojalvo,G Fasanella,A Fanfani,D Marlow,C Charlot,L Brianza,O Gutsche,M De Gruttola,Y Hsiung,E Kennedy,B Freund,S Tavernier,K Bloom,S Roy Chowdhury,I De Bruyn,S Banerjee,M Erdmann,R Lucas,R Mankel,E Barberis,N Cavallo,V Krychkine,S Keshri,D Gastler,T Williams,S Shalhout,S Dittmer,G Lanza,R.-S Lu,M Jeitler,P Zalewski,F Meng,M Naseri,I Shvetsov,C Dragoiu,S Bein,O Dvornikov,O Davignon,D Sperka,D Hare,I Azhgirey,A Kayis Topaksu,S Dey,F Fiori,J Bradmiller-Feld,J Pekkanen,S Somalwar,K Hatakeyama,A Korytov,Z Xu,F Golf,W Van Driessche,B Pavlov,G Alverson,N Chanon,H Rohringer,T Lampén,E Monteil,T Perry,M Stöver,K Androsov,A Holzner,C Bravo,W Lin,P Connor,S Jindariani,T Sculac,A De Cosa,O Bondu,S Toda,S Gascon,A Savoy-Navarro,D Meister,L Chtchipounov,F Micheli,C Civinini,D Gigi,A Harb,E Calvo,M Guilbaud,T Boccali,M Bachtis,K Piotrzkowski,G Sultanov,B Bylsma,A Braghieri,G Karapinar,Y Choi,L Bianchini,N Srimanobhas,M Klute,J Pela,H Sakulin,P Elmer,R Cavanaugh,A Magnani,C Riccardi,A Dabrowski,S Alderweireldt,E Gülmez,S Sagir,O Markin,I Iashvili,L Malgeri,J Flix,C Seez,D Puigh,L Bäni,J Rorie,F Bachmair,T Yetkin,E Di Marco,R Clare,P Kumari,A Melo,W Luo,B Diamond,D Trocino,K Lipka,Y Wang,S Gelli,J Bernardini,N Rad,M Abbrescia,S Bansal,T Mulholland,A Kamenev,G Vesztergombi,P Bortignon,J.-P Merlo,C Asawatangtrakuldee,L Benussi,B Roozbahani,G Perrin,P Lobelle Pardo,G Chen,L Di Matteo,I Katkov,A Sznajder,M Cipriani,P Shukla,Y Chen,M Kasemann,Z Tao,R Hughes,A Savin,F Lagarde,K Doroba,S Carrillo Moreno,A Olbrechts,I Dremin,A Apresyan,N Skatchkov,Y Maravin,D Vadruccio,A Hortiangtham,L Mundim,D Cieri,L Soffi,T Arndt,A Popov,M Guthoff,M Pesaresi,M Zeinali,L Martini,A Tapper,M Monteno,J Hollar,E Robutti,A Lee,J Thom,D Pinna,J Yelton,I Papadopoulos,P Millet,R Lander,T Ferguson,A Künsken,S Summers,G Organtini,M Rieger,N Kovalchuk,G Majumder,D Treille,F Fienga,A Mott,J Garcia-Ferrero,C Richardson,A Zghiche,M Plagge,S Pandey,D Marconi,S Schael,F Zhang,R Breedon,H Saka,P Rumerio,S Dutta,S Mrenna,S Fonseca De Souza,N Suwonjandee,D Wang,M Centis Vignali,R Magaña Villalba,S Gadrat,G Rauco,J Hauser,S Abu Zeid,A Zanetti,L Guiducci,J Haller,D Rankin,M Górski,T Pook,R Wallny,B Klima,J Rohlf,S Röcker,F Ferri,T Sakuma,C Nicolaou,G Mittag,M Schönenberger,J Erö,D Gulhan,A Kaminskiy,L Fiore,A Ostapchuk,A Giassi,C Harrington,F Mohamad Idris,I Bucinskaite,F Cossutti,M Pelliccioni,P Faccioli,A Léonard,W Si,R Frühwirth,Y Takahashi,I Van Parijs,A Vilela Pereira,K Mcdermott,P Miné,W Li,T Cheng,K Pedro,N Hörmann,J Lingemann,T Huang,A Adair,J Rodrigues Antunes,H Malbouisson,A Topkar,J Pata,D Kovalskyi,C.-E Wulz,S Abdullin,Y Kubota,M Foerster,N Pozzobon,T Strebler,Y Sirois,M Kaya,K Tatar,D Pellett,U Sarica,R Schöfbeck,S Sharma,M Franco Sevilla,R Erbacher,J Richman,M Jones,F Moortgat,S Salur,M Wolf,R Di Maria,S Belforte,V Khristenko,M Verzocchi,F Colombo,G Walia,D Lelas,C Jessop,A Hervé,J Schulz,D Velicanu,L Gutay,M Akbiyik,G Singh,W Waltenberger,U Dosselli,B Sutar,N Trevisani,S Troshin,R Fischer,C Bruner,R Redjimi,P Saxena,W Van Doninck,S Ha,C Schomakers,A Pfeiffer,A Van Spilbeeck,S Lisniak,D Nowatschin,A Grebenyuk,M Galanti,M Swartz,P Wittich,S Cihangir,T Sinthuprasith,M Zakaria,T Tuuva,P Azzi,S Kunori,M Gouzevitch,G Tonelli,A Lopez Virto,N Beliy,C Laner,K Bierwagen,M Dordevic,R Salerno,A Dasgupta,D Zou,A Nowack,D Saltzberg,J Vaitkus,M Hempel,M Cerrada,L Calligaris,S Buontempo,E Eskandari Tadavani,D Klein,C Campagnari,R Bainbridge,C Mironov,G Steinbrück,K Mondal,M Diemoz,C Grandi,A Fagot,A Perloff,A Martelli,S Sanders,J Gran,H Stadie,E Gurpinar,F Würthwein,A Massironi,I Redondo,M Heindl,A Gribushin,N Parashar,C Fernandez Bedoya,R Campanini,A Lanev,M Chertok,A Gizhko,J Wright,M Goncharov,J Wagner-Kuhr,Y Iiyama,R Heller,A Bonato,A Rosowsky,B Betchart,S Regnard,A Skuja,A Byszuk,S Maselli,S Beauceron,G Benelli,B Calpas,K Theofilatos,J Stupak,T Maerschalk,A Kharchilava,S Afanasiev,S Folgueras,Z Liu,A Apyan,G Kasieczka,G Anagnostou,R Khurana,R Lopes De Sá,I Puljak,P Van Mechelen,B Rahbaran,A Magitteri,R.-J Wang,M Peruzzi,S Undleeb,M Casarsa,N Kellams,A Tatarinov,W Carvalho,M Albrow,K Call,A Sobol,P Vischia,J Tuominiemi,B Vormwald,A Psallidas,P Montagna,K Yi,F Fabbri,F Ball,E Locci,J Jacob,S Thüer,D Sabes,G Daskalakis,E Torassa,D Futyan,N Cartiglia,S Chenarani,T Geralis,N Neumeister,R Horisberger,J Karancsi,R Lane,A Richards,K Matchev,P Piroué,S Choudhury,Z Zolkapli,C Barth,A.-C Le Bihan,K Nash,R Stringer,C Ochando,R Covarelli,M Oglakci,V Daponte,J Heilman,D Pitzl,S Ganguly,A Khatiwada,G Barbagli,I Miagkov,T Kolberg,L Fanò,A Levine,D Contardo,C Wang,P Verdier,A Nehrkorn,N Mccoll,F Yumiceva,S Padhi,G Breto,J Berryhill,A Spiezia,R Patel,S Nourbakhsh,J Roskes,A Elwood,B Tali,H Vogel,M Velasco,A Svyatkovskiy,V Bhatnagar,S Meola,M Kazana,Z Demiragli,L Lyons,R Gonzalez Suarez,G Petrucciani,A Khukhunaishvili,K Ranjan,S Cooperstein,D Poyraz,P Ronchese,A Mohammadi,P Hebda,A Ivanov,C Lucas,T Orimoto,T Toriashvili,S Wasserbaech,J Chaves,M Meschini,T Sarkar,J Mans,A Khan,M Kirakosyan,M Zanetti,S Xie,N Strobbe,A Nayak,A Boletti,T Peltola,M Mannelli,M Niedziela,J Mc Donald,M Turner,J Kim,P Eerola,B Maier,N Majumdar,N Dupont,H Jung,A Volkov,R Cousins,J Schieck,S Schnetzer,A Solano,D Haitz,V Oreshkin,S Tosi,M Meyer,S Paktinat Mehdiabadi,F Gasparini,O Kaya,D Leslie,K Borras,L Gray,R Carlin,B Francis,P Gras,K Beernaert,S Mersi,F Meijers,C Dozen,E Sexton-Kennedy,J Bowen,D Abbaneo,S Viret,R Loveless,M Dragicevic,R Paramatti,A Carnes,K Gill,G Masetti,L Favart,B Calvert,M Giffels,J Bunn,G Sieber,B Blumenfeld,J Chinellato,F Pantaleo,A Dishaw,J Olsen,S Lammel,S Jabeen,M Rovere,S Di Guida,D Stolp,C Uribe Estrada,J Kaisen,P Markowitz,A Garabedian,M Gavrilenko,R Mueller,B Hong,D Bourilkov,J Cuevas,A Santra,B De La Cruz,S Sarkar,J Salfeld-Nebgen,J Alimena,A Caudron,E Yazgan,A Cabrera,C Caputo,F Ricci-Tam,W Erdmann,T Libeiro,S Wang,Q Python,R Walsh,C Nuttens,V Matveev,A Randle-Conde,M Chen,M Olszewski,V Re,Y Roh,M De Mattia,L Orsini,N Manthos,Z Wang,A David,A Hinzmann,C O’Brien,C Sciacca,H Wei,C Flores,R Castaldi,A Toropin,N Colino,B Kilminster,A Venturi,L Silvestris,E Gottschalk,P Kyberd,F Cavallari,J Wetzel,M Selvaggi,Q Li,J D’Hondt,M Ignatenko,M Wayne,E Kuznetsova,A Moraes,S Wertz,S Khalil,V Calvelli,K Kadija,J Linacre,M Grimes,J Monroy,G Della Ricca,I Vorobiev,A Escalante Del Valle,V Perelygin,E Tziaferi,I Ahmed,L Brito,Y Onel,K Kothekar,V Blobel,H Reithler,N Bartosik,S Hasegawa,C Sander,M Hohlmann,P Spagnolo,P Sheldon,M Zientek,J Marco,J Incandela,L Taylor,G Abbiendi,Y Mao,D Hsu,P Van Hove,D Burns,K Deroover,G Eckerlin,H Prosper,H Mermerkaya,S Dogra,U Gasparini,I Suarez,B Ille,M Dittmar,A Mussgiller,J Steggemann,E Spencer,G Franzoni,K Maeshima,S Choi,P Turner,C Paus,M Squires,R Aggleton,C Favaro,A Lobanov,E Takasugi,M Alyari,F Matorras,I Vai,W Johns,A Custódio,L Antonelli,P Paganini,L Barone,A Stahl,H Lee,K Padeken,J.-C Fontaine,V Bhopatkar,M Jo,E Tiras,S Narayanan,A Fahim,Yu Andreev,A Sharma,H Mei,A Bornheim,F Couderc,T Eichhorn,E Wolfe,D Devetak,A Parker,J Lykken,R Friese,K Kaadze,C Mariotti,O Toldaiev,M Missiroli,A Vorobyev,P Luukka,V Ciulli,A Delgado,N Zaganidis,P Tan,M Musich,M Toms,V Savrin,Y Mohammed,M Gul,N Stefaniuk,P Cirkovic,Q Wang,S Bahinipati,N Dev,P Ma,E Meschi,G Roland,M Malberti,A Evans,M Stoye,S Paoletti,L Spiegel,C Tully,R Ruchti,M Seidel,H Kirschenmann,N Wickramage,K Dilsiz,A Juodagalvis,A Dominguez,C Autermann,S Damarseckin,C Bernet,M Paulini,S Shulha,C Biino,P Depasse,K Kousouris,S Fartoukh,G Safronov,G Landsberg,K Sung,C Amsler,R Hadjiiska,M Narain,M Friedl,G Grenier,E Paganis,P Symonds,M Mulders,J Velkovska,I Topsis-Giotis,S Simon,W Mcbrayer,A Agapitos,V Murzin,M Weinberg,Y Haddad,A Abdulsalam,K Klein,J Hakala,K Lannon,J Goldstein,S Harper,J Poehlsen,M Baber,P Jarry,E Butz,T Liu,A Beretvas,A Vartak,M Weber,K Deiters,C Calabria,D Winn,G Selvaggi,A Pozdnyakov,G Zumerle,D Del Re,M Tytgat,J Suarez Gonzalez,E Juska,J Pilot,L Litov,Ashok Kumar,N Tambe,D Piccolo,Th Müller,C Wissing,V Monaco,M Kaur,P Bloch,L Corpe,G Cerminara,A Colaleo,P Petkov,N Amapane,B Kargoll,C Mcginn,A Penzo,L Perrozzi,U Bhawandeep,L Forthomme,R Janjam,M Vutova,P Raics,C Henderson,M Dalchenko,F Zenoni,V Sola,V Krutelyov,A Romero,A Ranieri,P Harris,V Sharma,D Stickland,T Bose,R Harr,A Al-Bataineh,J Luetic,E Tuovinen,G Sguazzoni,Y Pakhotin,N Wardle,P Baringer,V Karjavin,L Shchutska,N Sur,H Mildner,A Pashenkov,C Vander Velde,S Kumar,J Keaveney,M Miñano Moya,C Kleinwort,P Goldenzweig,M Yalvac,J Lauwers,A Mehta,N Shumeiko,F Rebassoo,C Baus,V Dutta,D Fasanella,S Greene,L Vanelderen,L Caminada,S Hagopian,E Boos,Z Tu,M Flechl,N Eminizer,E Belchior Batista Das Chagas,A Modak,M Olschewski,F Thyssen,A Florent,S Donato,M Wang,D Rathjens,C Heidegger,W Funk,P Rebello Teles,H Bakhshiansohi,F Romeo,C Hwang,I Lokhtin,B Pollack,S Malik,P Bargassa,V Hagopian,P Jandir,L Skinnari,D Majumder,A Elliott-Peisert,C Hensel,A Meyer,S Carpinteyro,J Damgov,P Van Mulders,I Yu,A Zucchetta,A Geiser,G Mantovani,A Mestvirishvili,E Gallo,D Dutta,H Nogima,T Lenz,G Rolandi,R Lipton,A König,M Lethuillier,L Lista,P Musella,A Ahmad,M Bartók,F Hartmann,A Di Mattia,F Glege,S Albergo,L Ristori,M Merschmeyer,F Chlebana,S Lowette,D Gyun,K Lee,I Pozdnyakov,T Lomtadze,A Dimitrov,K Uchida,E Laird,H Neugebauer,T Hreus,K Long,A Vanhoefer,M Ruspa,J Seixas,M Azarkin,F Costanza,J Fulcher,F Xia,S Flowers,C Pistone,R Conway,F Simonetto,A Zarubin,J Pazzini,M Grothe,F Scheuch,S Fiorendi,J Härkönen,M Kovac,H Liu,B Courbon,A Kapoor,J Russ,A Perrotta,J Zhao,C Roland,S Petrushanko,L Viliani,T Verlage,M Walker,Z Lesko,G Miniello,F Lacroix,P Dauncey,W Ji,M Tripathi,K Skovpen,S Nandan,T Hebbeker,R Dell’Orso,M Haytmyradov,P Everaerts,A Quintario Olmeda,S De Visscher,A Junkes,E Ntomari,T James,D Tsiakkouri,S Lacaprara,E Asilar,K Stenson,P Lenzi,Q Ingram,H Kim,I Fisk,C Foudas,G Mitselmakher,J Ngadiuba,D Smith,K Sumorok,J Goodell,A Woodard,A Malta Rodrigues,C Contreras-Campana,A Tiko,J Leonard,P Zotto,E Paradas,S Marcellini,A Attikis,K Chatterjee,W Lustermann,Q Hassan,H Van Haevermaet,J Tucker,S Baur,N Smith,G Karapostoli,I Mikulec,A Lath,C Schäfer,N Van Remortel,A Nikitenko,M Felcini,V Karimäki,S Thakur,W Clarida,J Hauk,L Sulak,M Johnson,D Fehling,C Mueller,K Jung,B Mesic,L Moroni,O Charaf,J.-M Brom,M Della Negra,T Lapsien,J Letts,A Panagiotou,B Mahakud,C Grab,W Bertl,A Cocoros,A Marinov,F Pandolfi,D Leggat,J Nash,A Bylinkin,I Antropov,S Stoynev,N Pastrone,T Virdee,A Malakhov,M Kirsanov,T Reis,M Waqas,B Roland,I Kucher,L Pape,P Baillon,S Mitra,T Medvedeva,A Kropivnitskaya,L Teodorescu,D Curry,M Trovato,A Carvalho Antunes De Oliveira,M Naimuddin,V Veckalns,A Barker,F Blekman,A Degano,B Mangano,K Thapa,E Longo,H Wang,L Beck,D Hidas,P Meridiani,K Hurtado Anampa,S Taroni,E Garutti,S Sen,S Williamson,G Mavromanolakis,S Mukherjee,O Baron,P Busson,Z Wu,A Ackert,F Margaroli,P Barria,M Girone,J Mnich,M Krammer,M Dall’Osso,G De Lentdecker,D Taylor,C Battilana,S Tuo,M D’Alfonso,F Cenna,N Odell,L Perniè,A Whitbeck,N Varelas,W Lohmann,C Oropeza Barrera,M Northup,O Jesus,C Veelken,P Sorokin,P Giacomelli,F Ferro,A Shrinivas,M Guchait,B Michlin,C Neu,M Rodozov,U Heintz,V Jha,S Rappoccio,M Mulhearn,G Zevi Della Porta,C Florez,G Boudoul,E Dietz-Laursonn,J Gilmore,G Ryu,M Gardner,M Endres,E Contreras-Campana,I Golutvin,B Bilin,R Barbieri,S Thomas,K Nawrocki,A Tricomi,E Brondolin,S Lehti,J Roberts,J.-L Agram,U Goerlach,A Ershov,N Marinelli,S Turkcapar,Arun Kumar,M Citron,C Anelli,S Gninenko,V Blinov,A De Wit,L Lloret Iglesias,S Colafranceschi,J Hrubec,A Belloni,P Robmann,S Bhowmik,M Radziej,D Gelé,M Paganoni,S Lee,K Mandal,A Cimmino,I Marchesini,A Delgado Peris,F Primavera,J Yoo,O Driga,T Rodrigo,D Stuart,A Brinkerhoff,D Creanza,T Du Pree,S Pigazzini,H El Mamouni,A Askew,R Castello,V Petrov,M Cremonesi,L Brigliadori,J Wood,R Vidal,P Klabbers,M De Palma,A Starodumov,S Wayand,A Thea,P Thomassen,D Mason,P Sphicas,S Erdweg,G Hall,C Caillol,A Hart,P Janot,L Perrini,A Mertens,I D Reid ,H Castilla‐Valdez ,Vittorio Raoul Tavolaro ,K H M Kwok ,B C Choudhary ,N V Tran ,A A Bin Anuar ,M S Kim ,A Çakır ,Д Педрини ,T Schöerner-Sadenius ,I González Caballero ,G P Siroli ,S C Kao ,D Kotliński ,I A Cali ,P G Ferreira Parracho ,C Martínez Rivero ,W L Prado Da Silva ,S S Yu ,Supratik Mukhopadhyay ,I S Zorbakir ,H J Simonis ,K A Ulmer ,B R Yates ,J L Faure ,Z L Trocsanyi ,J Molnár ,F Nessi‐Tedaldi ,K Cankoçak ,W J Spalding ,Thea Klaeboe Aarrestad ,L A T Bauerdick ,Peter R Hobson ,R Démina ,J S H Lee ,Y D Oh ,M Grünewald ,J M Hernández ,O R Long ,Marco Esposito ,I J Cabrillo ,Gustavo Gil Da Silveira ,Sarah Seif El Nasr-Storey ,F R Cavallo ,F J M Geurts ,E Pérez ,V Brigljević ,Jagbir Singh ,C H Shepherd-Themistocleous ,J Malclès ,S Bilmiş ,P E Karchin ,Yue Shi Lai ,J P Fernández Ramos ,S B Beri ,D J Karmgard ,M Calderón De La Barca Sánchez ,R D Field ,B Ujvári ,M K Jha ,B Wysłouch ,P K Behera ,S Argirò ,J A Coughlan ,W D Zeuner ,P Milenović ,Н Голубев ,Simon Fink ,B Işıldak ,Raghav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli ,A T Meneguzzo ,A R Draeger ,T Ševa ,C F Gonźalez Herńandez ,T R Fernandez Perez Tomei ,D M Morse ,Silvia Goy López ,I Hoş ,M U Mozer ,J A Gómez ,М Фингер ,P Jež ,W A T Wan Abdullah ,D Ćutts ,А Калинин ,E W Hughes ,S H Seo ,Sam Daniel Mullin ,Jimin George ,S M Tan ,G Mäggi ,A C Marini ,Z Szillási ,D De Jesus Damião ,I C Park ,M B Tonjes ,S M Shaheen ,G E Bruno ,J M Marraffino ,Maksym Titov ,J P Cumalat ,Saša Mićanović ,Hannsjoerg Artur Weber ,J Królikowski ,J Königsberg ,Giuseppe Antonio Pierro ,Y T Duh ,Guillelmo Gomez Ceballos ,Q H Xu ,Saptaparna Bhattacharya ,S P Ratti ,J R Smith ,M W Arenton ,J G Bian ,É Chapon ,G Garcı́a ,J M Vizan Garcia ,D M Anderson ,Yu‐Wei Chang ,Yi Yang ,S J Qian ,P D Luckey ,A Zagoździńska ,J R Patterson ,Mauro Emanuele Dinardo ,V M Ghete ,Maria Chamizo Llatas ,E M Da Costa ,K Özdemir ,S Đurić ,M Ö Sahin ,K F Johnson ,Juan Ramon Castiñeiras De Saa ,A K Kalsi ,Luisa Alunni Solestizi ,B L Winer ,J Fernández Menéndez ,M Kröhn ,Donald Belknap ,G Martı́nez ,Feng Liu ,D M Raymond ,M C Fouz ,Ying Lü ,S R Wagner ,Frank Roscher ,P Maksimović ,Kin Ho Lo ,W A Khan ,S C Zenz ,D R Claes ,C Tuvé ,J P Chou ,J R Gonźalez Ferńandez ,Manuel Olmedo Negrete ,I K Furic ,W L Aldá Júnior ,G Hamel De Monchenault ,M T Meinhard ,A C Benvenuti ,Y M Tzeng ,А Спиридонов ,M R Monge ,Benjamin Charles Radburn-Smith ,M T Lucchini ,T J Kim ,Imad Baptiste Laktineh ,Mirena Ivova Paneva ,L M Huertas Guativa ,D H Kim ,P G Mercadante ,C A Carrillo Montoya ,J G Branson ,B Akgün ,M Besançon ,Luis Monsonis Romero ,Chiara De Martin ,Riccardo Andrea Manzoni ,P M Ribeiro Cipriano ,А Александров ,J Andreä ,A V Gritsan ,Kristan Allan Hahn ,Jing Fan ,H Flächer ,Maria Florencia Canelli ,G N Kim ,S I Cooper ,A Rossi ,H W Wulsin ,C A Bernardes ,W H Smith ,Z S Demiroglu ,Zainol Abidin Ibrahim ,Anne-Laure Pequegnot ,S K Park ,Diego Matos Figueiredo ,В Сулимов ,S B Oh ,G Gökbulut ,R K Dewanjee ,P K Netrakanti ,D Horváth ,F Özok ,Y F Liu ,M N Yusli ,D M Newbold ,K Krajczár ,D K Sahoo ,V A Giakoumopoulou ,V Lemaı̂tre ,M T Grippo ,G M Innocenti ,G B Cerati ,R P Gandrajula ,J R Adams ,Clemencia Mora Herrera ,J J Brooke ,J B Sauvan ,O Buchmüller ,W T Ford ,Mara Senghi Soares ,Y H Shin ,G P Van Onsem ,Rocky Bala Garg ,N Godinović ,G M Dallavalle ,Manqi Ruan ,J C Sanabria ,P H Chen ,J M Lawhorn ,G B Yu ,A Rinkevičius ,D J A Cockerill ,P T Cox ,A Sánchez-Hernández ,В Макаренко ,Maria Margherita Obertino ,Gabriella Pugliese ,O González López ,A Çelik ,S M Etesami ,A J Zsigmond ,I Dumanoğlu ,J M Grados Luyando ,F Siklér ,Jorge F De Trocóniz ,F M Stober ,R Y Zhu ,M M Baarmand ,C H Jiang ,H B Newman ,A G Delannoy ,H Oğul ,F L Navarria ,C Ávila ,J D Ruiz Alvarez ,K Höepfner ,J Milošević ,C M Kuo ,T H Doan ,M A B Md Ali ,K F Chen ,Jianping Han ,P R Dudero ,C S Moon ,A M Sirunyan ,M I Josa ,M Schmitt ,H S Chen ,A A Abdelalim ,S Çerçi ,R M Brown ,L Felď ,R R Betts ,Alberto Orso Maria Iorio ,S Dubé ,P Adžić ,You-Hao Chang ,V D Elvira ,E W Vaandering ,P H Butler ,Jeremie Alexandre Merlin ,Jia Fu Low ,C Peña ,P Martínez Ruiz Del Arbol ,J R Komaragiri ,Alexey Finkel ,Rajdeep Mohan Chatterjee ,A W Jung ,M R Adams ,E A Yetkin ,G M Bilei ,K Buńkowski ,Gian Luca Pinna Angioni ,E M Gregores ,B P Padley ,D Ferenček ,P C Bhat ,S W Lee ,M Déjardin ,P H Hansen ,R López-Fernández ,M S Ryu ,Mukund Varma ,F L Alves ,V J Smith ,Sergio F Novaes ,L F Chaparro Sierra ,Lloyd Stanley Durkin ,A Calderón ,Michal Bluj ,L K Saini ,A Hernández-Almada ,M Fernández ,E Currás ,S C Tonwar ,Joern Schwandt ,G M Chen ,U K Yang ,Christopher Clarke ,H F Heath ,J D Tapia ∋Takaki ,I D Sandoval Gonzalez ,F Pauß ,K S Lee ,J W Gary ,A H Ball ,J F Schulte ,G A Alves ,E Clément ,Michael Benjamin Andrews ,M Lipiński ,Humberto Antonio Salazar Ibarguen ,Karl Matthew Ecklund ,M A Shah ,A Adıgüzel ,H Białkowska ,D H Miller ,E J Tonelli Manganote ,H K Wöhri ,S Sánchez Cruz ,Ž Antunović ,G P Heath ,J H Kim ,M J Kortelainen ,G B Mohanty ,A K Mohanty ,G Önengüt ,Mythra Varun Nemallapudi ,S K Swain ,J E Cole ,A García-Bellido ,A C Mignerey ,V Dūdėnas ,S K Ghosh ,S M Heindl ,Piero Giorgio Verdini ,C E Gerber ,J Hoß ,D Blöch ,I R Tomalin ,Hans-Christian Kaestli ,Jorge Luis Rodriguez ,David Romero Abad ,S Perriès ,Bilal Kiani ,A Rýd ,P Garcı́a-Abia ,Joaquin Emilo Siado ,G I Veres ,V Reković ,P A Razis ,В Жуков ,A Rácz ,T W Wang ,H D Yoo ,M E Pol ,V Veszprémi ,H R Hoorani ,G R Snow ,J A Brochero Cifuentes ,J G Acosta ,Raymond Patrick Kenny ,D J Hofman ,E A De Wolf ,Sandra Padula ,Р Тенчини ,G Gómez ,V E Barnes ,J R Vlimant ,Eric Christian Chabert ,D C Son ,J C Ruiz Vargas ,R M Harris ,N J Hadley ,Y Güler ,S C Eno ,E E Kangal ,N Filipović ,G S F Stephans ,R G Kellogg ,J F Tsai ,В Качанов ,Simranjit Singh Chhibra ,B E Cox ,T A Gómez Espinosa ,R Plačakytė ,N Béni ,J M Hogan ,Yongjie Xin ,T Šuša ,L M Pant ,S Czellár ,Jesús Puerta Pelayo ,H W K Cheung ,C Hajdú ,M A Ciocci ,M J Costa ,M K Kiesel ,J N Butler ,S M A Ghiasi Shirazi

doi:10.1103/physrevlett.118.122301

Abstract

Charge-dependent azimuthal particle correlations with respect to the second-order event plane in p-Pb and PbPb collisions at a nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass energy of 5.02TeV have been studied with the CMS experiment at the LHC. The measurement is performed with a three-particle correlation technique, using two particles with the same or opposite charge within the pseudorapidity range |η|<2.4, and a third particle measured in the hadron forward calorimeters (4.4<|η|<5). The observed differences between the same and opposite sign correlations, as functions of multiplicity and η gap between the two charged particles, are of similar magnitude in p-Pb and PbPb collisions at the same multiplicities. These results pose a challenge for the interpretation of charge-dependent azimuthal correlations in heavy ion collisions in terms of the chiral magnetic effect.

Highlights

In relativistic heavy ion collisions, metastable domains of gluon fields may form with nontrivial topological configurations [1,2,3,4]
The charge separation can be characterized by the P-odd sine term (a1) in a Fourier decomposition of the particle azimuthal distribution [12]: dN dφ
Measurements of the charge-dependent three-particle correlator are shown in Fig. 1 as a function of the jΔηj between charged particles α and β with the same and opposite signs, in 220 for p-Pb and the multiplicity PbPb collisions raatngpeffisffiffiN1ffiffiN8ffiffi51⁄4≤5N.0ot2rfkflTinee V

Summary

Introduction

In relativistic heavy ion collisions, metastable domains of gluon fields may form with nontrivial topological configurations [1,2,3,4]. The measurement is presented in different charge combinations as functions of event multiplicity and pseudorapidity (η) difference of correlated particles. [35], are used to define the event charged-particle multiplicity (Notrfkfline) and to perform correlation measurements.

Results

Conclusion