Objective Bayesian methods for one-sided testing

Abstract

The one-sided testing problem can be naturally formulated as the comparison between two nonnested models. In an objective Bayesian setting, that is, when subjective prior information is not available, no general method exists either for deriving proper prior distributions on parameters or for computing Bayes factor and model posterior probabilities. The encompassing approach solves this difficulty by converting the problem into a nested model comparison for which standard methods can be applied to derive proper priors. We argue that the usual way of encompassing does not have a Bayesian justification, and propose a variant of this method that provides an objective Bayesian solution. The solution proposed here is further extended to the case where nuisance parameters are present and where the hypotheses to be tested are separated by an interval. Some illustrative examples are given for regular and non-regular sampling distributions.