Nursing homes: a suitable alternative to hospital care for older people in the UK?

Abstract

Over the past two decades nursing homes have become the major supplier of long-stay care for frail older people in the UK. Demographic projections indicate that the volume of nursing home places will continue to increase to keep pace with demand and that the population of homes will become steadily more dependent. Little systematic research exists to indicate how nursing home care compares with hospital care; the evidence that does exists tends to be restricted to local studies and thus is not generalizable. Local studies indicate that in both care settings there are shortfalls in terms of meeting basic quality of care standards. Despite this, there is obvious potential for nursing homes to act as an alternative to hospitalization, provided that there is suitable access for residents to specialist care and, for example, appropriate administration of medicines. Proposed changes in government policy will introduce more uniform standards in nursing homes and associated inspection structures and procedures. However, further research is needed to ascertain the clinical and consumer value of different interventions in nursing homes, and the cost-benefit of enhancing provision available in terms of preventing or forestalling demand on hospitals or reducing hospital length of stay. In the light of the commitment to develop evidence based practice, it is important that such research is urgently advanced to eliminate poor practice. In our rights conscious society, future generations of older people are unlikely to be as tolerant of substandard care.