Numerical estrangement and integration between symbolic and non-symbolic numerical information: Task-dependence and its link to math abilities in adults

Abstract

Most adults have access to two different number systems to represent numerical information: an exact number system, which relies on different forms of number symbols to represent exact numerical information, and an approximate number system, which allows for approximate estimates of numerical quantities. Here we investigate the integration between the symbolic and non-symbolic numerical information (i.e., “numerical integration”), and how numerical integration relates to adults' formal math abilities. We administered two tasks to measure numerical integration. For a number comparison task with non-symbolic dot arrays and Arabic numerals, participants indicated the larger of two sequentially presented stimuli that were same-format (dot-dot or numeral-numeral), or mixed-format (dot-numeral or numeral-dot). For a number-letter discrimination task, participants identified Arabic numerals or letter pairs that co-occurred with dot arrays (matching or mismatching the quantity represented by the numeral). In the number comparison task, participants were significantly slower when comparing mixed-format stimuli, especially when Arabic numerals were presented first and dot arrays second, suggesting estrangement between symbolic and non-symbolic numerical information and an asymmetry depending on the order in which the numerical information is presented. In contrast, in the number-letter discrimination task, participants were significantly faster in number-letter discrimination for matching dot arrays and numerals, suggesting integration between symbolic and non-symbolic numerical information. Surprisingly, some measures of numerical estrangement derived from the number comparison task significantly correlated with adults' performance on a standardized math assessment. Thus, we conclude that numerical integration or estrangement is task-dependent, and adults with greater levels of symbolic estrangement tend to have higher math skills.