Number of Variables for Graph Differentiation and the Resolution of Graph Isomorphism Formulas

Abstract

We show that the number of variables and the quantifier depth needed to distinguish a pair of graphs by first-order logic sentences exactly match the complexity measures of clause width and depth needed to refute the corresponding graph isomorphism formula in propositional narrow resolution. Using this connection, we obtain upper and lower bounds for refuting graph isomorphism formulas in (normal) resolution. In particular, we show that if k is the minimum number of variables needed to distinguish two graphs with n vertices each, then there is an n O ( k ) resolution refutation size upper bound for the corresponding isomorphism formula, as well as lower bounds of 2 k -1 and k for the treelike resolution size and resolution clause space for this formula. We also show a (normal) resolution size lower bound of exp (Ω ( k 2 / n )) for the case of colored graphs with constant color class sizes. Applying these results, we prove the first exponential lower bound for graph isomorphism formulas in the proof system SRC-1, a system that extends resolution with a global symmetry rule, thereby answering an open question posed by Schweitzer and Seebach.