Novel scoring system for differentiating parechovirus-A3 and enterovirus infection in neonates and young infants

Abstract

BackgroundParechovirus-A3 (PeV-A3) and the enteroviruses (EVs) are the most common viral pathogens responsible for sepsis and meningoencephalitis in neonates and young infants; however, differences in the clinical presentations of two infections are not well described. ObjectivesTo describe the clinical presentations of PeV-A3- and EVs-related diseases and develop a novel scoring system to differentiate two diseases. Study designThis prospective study used real-time PCR and genetic sequencing to evaluate viral etiologies of febrile neonates and infants <4 months with suspected sepsis or meningoencephalitis in Niigata area, Japan, in 2014-2016. The clinical manifestations of PeV-A3- and EVs-infected patients were compared, and a novel scoring system was developed after identifying the most distinguishable clinical findings, followed by the external cohort validation. ResultsIn 210 patients evaluated, we identified 56 PeV-A3-infected (27%) and 43 EVs-infected (20%) patients. The following clinical manifestations were significant in PeV-A3-infected patients, as compared with EVs-infected patients; a higher body temperature (38.9°C vs. 38.5°C, P < .01) and heart rate (181/min vs. 168/min, P = .01), cold extremities (72% vs. 34%, P < .01) and skin mottling (65% vs. 23%, P < .01), lower white blood cell count (5,200/μL vs. 8,900/μL, P < .01) and incidence of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pleocytosis (2% vs. 63%, P < .01). Using some of these significant findings, the scoring system successfully distinguished the diseases (accuracy: 86% and 83% for the derivative and external validation cohorts, respectively). ConclusionsWe found significant clinical manifestations in PeV-A3-infected patients compared to EVs-infected patients. The scoring system may be helpful to distinguish two infections, especially at onset of outbreak.