Normal Range of Movement During Rotation Stress Testing for the Alar Ligaments: An Observational Study

Abstract

ObjectiveThe purpose of this study was to determine the normal range of rotation occurring during rotation stress testing for alar ligament integrity and to ascertain whether rotation range on testing is affected by an individual's age. MethodIn this observational study, 88 people aged 18 to 86 years old with no current neck problems or known risk factors for craniocervical instability underwent rotation stress testing for the alar ligaments. The test was performed in each direction in neutral, flexion, and extension, with the participant both sitting and supine. Rotation range was recorded using an electromagnetic movement tracking system. Range was assessed overall and then compared by 10-year age groups using analysis of variance. Reliability of measurements was assessed by intraclass correlation coefficient(2,1) and standard error of measurement. ResultsMean angles of upper cervical rotation ranged between 10.91° (standard deviation 3.38°) to 16.12° (standard deviation 5.13°). Overall measured rotation ranged from 1.37° to 33.22°. Participants in older age groups generally displayed reduced rotation; however, the reduction was less than 4°. Reliability of rotation measurements was good to excellent, with the intraclass correlation coefficient ranging from 0.80 to 0.99. ConclusionsNormal range of rotation measured during stress testing for the alar ligament varied widely but did not exceed 33o. All values measured in this study fell below recommendations for ligament integrity. Age-related change was not clinically significant in the interpretation of this test in this asymptomatic population.