Nonresponder does not mean not better: Improvement in nonsymptom domains in complex depressed patients who are not symptomatic responders to intensive treatment

Abstract

In treatment studies of depression, response is typically defined as a 50% or greater reduction in symptom severity. However, multiple surveys of depressed patients have found that patients prioritize improved functioning and quality of life objectives over symptom improvement as the most important goal of treatment. The goal of the present study is to widen the lens of assessing outcome by examining response in nonsymptom domains in patients who are, by convention, considered nonresponders to treatment. Eight hundred and forty-four patients with major depressive disorder completed the Remission from Depression Questionnaire (RDQ), a self-report measure that assesses multiple constructs considered by patients to be relevant to assessing treatment outcome. At discharge, the patients made a global rating of the effectiveness of treatment. The 517 patients who were nonresponders on the depression symptom subscale of the RDQ are the focus of this report. The patients showed significant levels of improvement from admission to discharge in all nonsymptom domains, with medium to large effect sizes. Approximately one-third of the patients were responders on at least 1 of the nonsymptom domains. The failure to meet the conventional definition of treatment response based on symptom severity does not preclude significant improvement in nonsymptom domains.