Noninvasive Detection of Hippocampal Epileptiform Activity on Scalp Electroencephalogram

Abstract

The hippocampus is a highly epileptogenic brain region, yet over 90% of hippocampal epileptiform activity (HEA) cannot be identified on scalp electroencephalogram (EEG) by human experts. Currently, detection of HEA requires intracranial electrodes, which limits our understanding of the role of HEA in brain diseases. To develop and validate a machine learning algorithm that accurately detects HEA from a standard scalp EEG, without the need for intracranial electrodes. In this diagnostic study, conducted from 2008 to 2021, EEG data were used from patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and healthy controls (HCs) to train and validate a deep neural network, HEAnet, to detect HEA on scalp EEG. Participants were evaluated at tertiary-level epilepsy centers at 2 academic hospitals: Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) or Brigham and Women's Hospital (BWH). Included in the study were patients aged 12 to 78 years with a clinical diagnosis of TLE and HCs without epilepsy. Patients with TLE and HCs with a history of intracranial surgery were excluded from the study. Simultaneous intracranial EEG and/or scalp EEG. Performance was assessed using cross-validated areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC ROC) and precision-recall curve (AUC PR) and additional clinically relevant metrics. HEAnet was trained and validated using data sets that were derived from a convenience sample of 141 eligible participants (97 with TLE and 44 HCs without epilepsy) whose retrospective EEG data were readily available. Data set 1 included the simultaneous scalp EEG and intracranial electrode recordings of 51 patients with TLE (mean [SD] age, 40.7 [15.9] years; 30 men [59%]) at MGH. An automatically generated training data set with 972 095 positive HEA examples was created, in addition to a held-out expert-annotated testing data set with 22 762 positive HEA examples. HEAnet's performance was validated on 2 independent scalp EEG data sets: (1) data set 2 (at MGH; 24 patients with TLE and 20 HCs; mean [SD] age, 42.3 [16.2] years; 17 men [39%]) and (2) data set 3 (at BWH; 22 patients with TLE and 24 HCs; mean [SD] age, 43.0 [14.4] years; 20 men [43%]). For single-event detection of HEA on data set 1, HEAnet achieved a mean (SD) AUC ROC of 0.89 (0.01) and a mean (SD) AUC PR of 0.39 (0.03). On external validation with data sets 2 and 3, HEAnet accurately distinguished TLE from HC (AUC ROC of 0.88 and 0.95, respectively) and predicted epilepsy lateralization with 100% and 92% accuracy, respectively. HEAnet tracked dynamic changes in HEA in response to seizure medication adjustments and performed comparably with human experts in diagnosing TLE from 1-hour scalp EEG recordings, diagnosing TLE in several individuals that experts missed. Without reducing specificity, addition of HEAnet to human expert EEG review increased sensitivity for diagnosing TLE in humans from 50% to 58% to 63% to 67%. Results of this diagnostic study suggest that HEAnet provides a novel, noninvasive, quantitative, and clinically relevant biomarker of hippocampal hyperexcitability in humans.