Non-targeted effects and the dose response for heavy ion tumor induction

Abstract

Non-targeted effects (NTE), including bystander effects in neighbor cells of cells directly hit by radiation tracks and genomic instability in the progeny of irradiated cells, challenge traditional radiation protection paradigms on Earth. It is thus of interest to understand how NTE could impact our understanding of cancer risks from galactic cosmic rays (GCR), which are comprised of high-energy protons and heavy ions. The most comprehensive data set for tumor induction by heavy ions is the induction of Harderian gland tumors in mice by high-energy protons, helium, neon, iron and niobium ions after doses of 0.05 to several Gy. We report on an analysis of these data that compares a dose response model motivated by the conventional targeted effects (TE) model to one which includes a dose response term descriptive of non-targeted effects (NTE) in cell culture. Results show that a NTE model provides an improved fit to the Harderian gland data over the TE model. Relative biological effectiveness (RBE) factors are shown to have much larger values at low doses based on a NTE model than the maximum RBE estimates based on estimates of the ratio of initial linear slopes of heavy ions compared to γ-rays in the TE model. Our analysis provides important in vivo support for the deviation from linear dose responses at low doses for high LET radiation, which are best explained by a NTE model.