Non-Private Health Insurance Plans and Delayed Access to a Specialty Pediatric Concussion Clinic

Abstract

Background:Delayed access to specialty concussion clinic results in a 5.5 times greater risk of protracted recovery and higher costs to the healthcare system. Previous research highlighting health equity disparities has shown that being female, of minoritized status, or having non-private health insurance doubles the risk of delayed access to specialty concussion clinic.Purpose:The purpose of this project was to better characterize those with non-private insurance receiving care at a specialty concussion clinic and examine factors potentially contributing to delayed access to specialty care.Methods:Medical records of 231 patients with non-private insurance were reviewed. Patients were divided into two categories (Equivocal, Unequivocal) based on handbook language requiring PCP referral. Equivocal were insurance plans with ambiguous language requiring PCP referral. Unequivocal were insurance plans with a specific statement requiring a referral. Access to clinic was defined as early (0-7 days) or delayed (8-20 days). Descriptive stats were run to determine the number of males/females, providers previously seen, and if previously seen in the Emergency Room (ER). A one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was run along with Tukey post hoc to determine if there were any significant differences between number of previous providers seen and previous ER visit in the average number of days to specialty care.Results:Most patients, 97% (n=224) were in the equivocal category. The equivocal category was mostly male (n=145, 64.7%) and of minoritized status (n=177, 79%) with over 35% (n=80) being delayed to clinic (M=6.8 days, SD=4.7). The majority of those in the equivocal category (n=157, 67.9%) saw at least one previous provider, 53% being evaluated first in an ER (n=119). Those with a previous provider visit took longer to seek specialty care (F(2,230) = 3.54, p = 0.03). Those seeing two previous providers (M=9.4 days) on average took more days to get to initial specialty care compared to seeing one previous provider (M=6.8 days) or going straight to clinic (M=6.2 days).Conclusion:Patients with a non-private health insurance plan experience delayed access to specialty concussion care. Those with equivocal insurance plan language were delayed to clinic, seen by multiple providers, and first evaluated in the Emergency Room. Non-private insurance is often financially subsidized, yet the equivocal language in these policies could be a detriment contributing to overall increases in health care costs and quality of care for those who have sustained a concussion.