NOB suppression by organic pollutants in mainstream single-stage partial nitrification/anammox (PN/A) process: Experimental evidence and modelling investigation

Abstract

Effectively and stably suppressing nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) under mainstream conditions is difficult for the wide application of the partial nitrification/anammox (PN/A) process. In this work, a continuous-flow single-stage PN/A reactor experiencing nitrate accumulation was restored by increasing the influent chemical oxygen demand (COD) concentrations. Experimental results showed that the total nitrogen removal efficiency quickly increased from 70 ± 2.54 % to 84 ± 1.21 % while effluent nitrate concentrations dropped from 30 ± 4.07 mg N/L to 10 ± 3.18 mg N/L following increasing the influent COD concentrations. A modified and calibrated mathematical model was employed to quantify the nitrogen conversion process and microorganism distributions under various influent COD levels. The detailed nitrogen metabolism network was calculated by labeling the source and sink of nitrite and nitrate. Simulation results revealed that influent COD suppressed NOB activity and enhanced anammox bacteria (AMX) activity in a short-term dynamic state while leading to the elimination of NOB and enrichment of the AMX under long-term pseudo-steady state. N-metabolism simulation results indicated that more nitrite (from 46.62 mg N/L to 55.05 mg N/L) was diverted to AMX with the assistance of heterotrophic bacteria (HET). NOB was outcompeted due to the dual pressure of competing with HET and AMX for oxygen and nitrite, respectively. Microbial analysis solidly supported these findings, showing that Candidatus_kuenenia, Thauera and Denitratisoma were enriched, while the relative abundance of Nitrospira decreased after COD addition. These findings demonstrate the potential of using organic pollutants to suppress and eliminate NOB, thereby enhancing the stability and efficiency of mainstream PN/A reactors.