Nitrogen leaching following clear-cutting and soil scarification at a Scots pine site – A modelling study of a fertilization experiment

Abstract

Boreal forest stands fertilized with nitrogen (N) might be susceptible to elevated N leaching following clear-cutting, with consequences for water quality and soil acidification. Here, we studied a forest fertilization experiment with N, 165 Hagfors, in Sweden during the first six years (2006–2011) following clear-cutting. The N fertilization treatments were 0kgha−1 (0N) and 450kgha−1 of N (450N), supplied during 1981–1992 to a Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) stand: the stand was harvested in March 2006. Following clear-cutting, disc trenching was performed and furrows (F), ridges (R) and areas in-between two furrows (IB) were created. We calculated the N leaching fluxes and ecosystem N budget during 2006–2011 as affected by previous N fertilization, disc trenching and interactions thereof, at Hagfors by the use of a process-based biogeophysical ecosystem model (CoupModel). The model was calibrated against measurements of soil water and temperature dynamics and previously reported measurements of N in soil solution, soil organic matter and vegetation biomass. Criteria for acceptance of model estimates were based on the range enclosed by the 95% confidence intervals of the mean of the field data used in calibration sampled at low frequency (1–2 occasions) and a combination of the mean error and the coefficient of the determination for variables sampled at a higher frequency (28–1921 occasions). The accepted model estimates of the mean annual leaching rates of N were 3.1 (range 1.4–22.7) and 2.4 (range 0.8–7.0) kgha−1 of Nyear−1 in the treatments 0N and 450N, respectively, without disc trenching. Disc trenching increased N leaching during the regeneration phase, more so in the 450N treatment (mean 6.1, range 1.9–16.7kgha−1 of Nyear−1) than in the 0N treatment (mean 4.6, range 1.9–12.9kgha−1 of N year−1). Overall, differences in the posterior model parameter estimates between N treatments and disc trenched treatments F, R and IB were related to the soil physical component: the differences resulted in enhanced drainage in the disc trenched treatments. We conclude that vegetation biomass N accumulation controlled soil water N leaching, and disc trenching increased N leaching from the previously N fertilized plots at Hagfors by its effects on water drainage flow and vegetation N uptake. This finding warrants more research since N fertilization followed by soil scarification in boreal forests is a practice which may increase in the future.