Nitrogen fertilizer replacement value of stockpiled and rotted dairy cattle manures for corn (Zea mays L.) from a long-term study

Abstract

Context or problemAnimal manure is an excellent renewable source of plant nutrients, but the correct quantification of nutrient equivalents is affected by manure type and application rate as well as weather conditions that impact crop yields Objective or research questionThe objectives from a 32-year field experiment were to (1) compare the effects of mineral N fertilization and solid dairy cattle manure on corn grain yield; (2) determine the manure N fertilizer replacement value (NFRV), and (3) quantify environmental factors, mainly the impact of total precipitation during the critical period (silking) on corn yield and manure NFRV. MethodsA field experiment under continuous corn with annual manure application was conducted over 32 years in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Corn yield data were categorized into low, intermediate, and high N response groups. ResultsOn an equivalent amount of manure organic N basis, NFRVs were, on average, 0.38 (±0.02) for stockpiled manure (SM) and 0.27 (±0.02) for incompletely composted or rotted manure (RM), with a wide range of 0.12 (±0.02), 0.28 (±0.02), and 0.37 (±0.04) for RM, and 0.16 (±0.04), 0.39 (±0.03), and 0.48 (±0.04) for SM under the low, intermediate, and high N response conditions, respectively. Supplementing 100 kg synthetic fertilizer N ha−1 in low RM (50 Mg ha−1 fresh weight; f.w.), and 50 kg fertilizer N ha−1 in high RM (100 Mg ha−1 f.w.) application rates decreased NFRVs under low and intermediate N response conditions, whereas the addition of similar synthetic N in the corresponding SM rates reduced NFRVs only under low N response conditions. ConclusionsBased on the 32-year long-term study, we documented that the maximum economic synthetic N fertilizer rates for continuous corn cropping varied from 117 to 179 kg N ha−1 under the low N response, from 127 to 283 kg N ha−1 under the intermediate N response, and from 227 to 289 kg N ha−1 under the high N response conditions. The NFRVs of solid cattle manures varied according to corn yield-N response levels. Implications or significanceOur findings showed that the response of corn yields to manure NFRV depends on the level of yield-N response and climatic conditions. It also indicated the importance of soil organic amendments for improving the climate resilience of corn production, while simultaneously meeting the demand for more sustainable nutrient management of soil resources.