Nitrogen enrichments in sheeted dikes and gabbros from DSDP/ODP/IODP Hole 504B and 1256D: Insights into nitrogen recycling in Central America and global subduction zones

Abstract

The fate of subducted crustal nitrogen (N) in modern-style subduction zones remains hotly debated from nearly complete return to the surface via arc volcanoes to net ingassing into the deep mantle beyond the sub-arc depth. One of the major obstacles for this controversy is the lack of constraint on the input N flux from altered oceanic crust (AOC). While notable N enrichment by low-temperature hydrothermal alteration has been widely reported in the upper volcanic section of AOC, N behavior during high-temperature alteration of the underlying intrusive oceanic crust (i.e., sheeted dikes and gabbros) remains poorly understood. Here we examined the bulk-rock N concentrations and isotopic compositions of the AOC (with a main focus on sheeted dikes and gabbros, yet including basalts from sections that have not been examined before) from ODP/IODP Hole 1256D and DSDP/ODP Hole 504B, which are two reference sites for subducting material into the warm Central America (CA) subduction zone. The results show that the intrusive sections have comparable N concentrations and isotopic compositions to their overlying upper volcanic rocks at 1256D (sheeted dikes: 16.4±7.2 ppm and −1.3±1.5‰; gabbros: 11.3±5.6 ppm and +1.3±1.0‰; basalts: 11.8±3.8 ppm and +0.9±1.7‰) and 504B (sheeted dikes: 7.6±2.1 ppm and +2.1±1.7‰; basalts: 8.0±3.8 ppm and +2.4±2.9‰). These data can be readily explained by mixing between inherited mantle N and secondary N mostly derived from seawater/sediments with a minor contribution from abiotic N2 reduction. The secondary N in sheeted dikes and gabbros was mainly incorporated at moderate- to high-temperature (>250 °C) alteration stages and likely resides in chlorite, secondary plagioclase and amphibole. These new data clearly indicate that the intrusive section of AOC is a non-negligible N reservoir. Using these data, together with previously published N concentration data of basalts from Holes 1256D and 504B and of subducting sediments from Hole 1039B offboard the CA trench, we obtained a total N input flux of 3.1±0.6 × 109 mol‧yr−1 to 4.0±0.8 × 109 mol‧yr−1 into the CA trench. Integrating recently published N output flux of 0.58 × 109 to 1.4±0.6 × 109 mol‧yr−1 at the CA arc, an N recycling efficiency of 15±3–45±5% was yielded for the CA margin, indicating that up to 55±5–85±3% of subducted slab N is possibly transported beyond the sub-arc depth in this warm subduction zone. Based on the new finding of comparable N enrichment between basalts and intrusive oceanic crust, our modeling also gave a revised N recycling efficiency of 12±10–17±12% for the cold Izu-Bonin-Mariana (IBM) subduction zone, which is consistent with previous estimate of 4–17%. While these new estimates do not provide a conclusive constraint on the effect of subduction-zone thermal structure on N recycling, they consistently suggest that a large fraction of slab N (>50%) can survive the sub-arc filter and be delivered to the deeper mantle in global subduction zones.