NEIGHBOR RELATEDNESS AND COMPETITIVE PERFORMANCE IN IMPATIENS CAPENSIS (BALSAMINACEAE): A TEST OF THE RESOURCE PARTITIONING HYPOTHESIS

Abstract

The Elbow Room hypothesis for the maintenance of sex depends upon the assumption that intraspecific resource partitioning occurs and increases in magnitude with decreasing genetic similarity of competitors. This assumption leads to the prediction that plants should have greater fitness in competition with nonrelatives than in competition with siblings. Moreover, if a population displays fine scale genetic structure and genetic similarity declines with distance, then resource partitioning should increase with increasing geographical distance between the source locations of the competing genotypes. We tested these predictions in a greenhouse experiment by subjecting inbred Impatiens capensis seedlings to four types of competitors: 1) inbred full sibs; 2) inbred nonrelatives from the same source location; 3) inbred nonrelatives from a source location 30 m away; and 4) inbred nonrelatives from another population approximately 1 km distant. Plant dry weight at harvest increased significantly with seed weight and earlier emergence date, decreased significantly with seed weight and earlier emergence date of the competitor, and varied significantly among maternal seed families. However, there was no significant effect of competitor relatedness or distance between parental locations. The experiment therefore failed to support the resource partitioning hypothesis.