Negativity on two sides: Individuals with borderline personality disorder form negative first impressions of others and are perceived negatively by them.

Abstract

Impression formation is vital for social interactions and theorized to be negatively biased in borderline personality disorder (BPD). We assessed 2 sides of impression formation in BPD: BPD individuals as raters who form first impressions and as targets of others' first impressions. We further investigated BPD-Rater × Target interactions. We showed videos of 52 targets (26 BPD, 26 healthy controls [HC], 46% male) to unmedicated women with BPD (n = 32), a clinical control group with social anxiety disorder (SAD; n = 29), and a HC group (n = 37). We hypothesized (a) that BPD raters would evaluate targets more negatively than SAD and HC raters. Indeed, BPD raters evaluated targets as significantly less trustworthy, less approachable, and less similar to themselves than HC raters. Descriptively, rater groups showed a pattern of BPD < SAD < HC, but the differences between SAD and both other rater groups failed to reach statistical significance. We further expected (b) HC raters to evaluate BPD targets more negatively than HC targets, and results supported this hypothesis. Lastly, we hypothesized (c) that BPD raters would perceive BPD targets more positively than HC targets, which was not supported. We discuss how negative first impressions by and of BPD individuals could contribute to loneliness and interpersonal dysfunction and suggest potential interventions. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).