Navier-Stokes computations of vortex asymmetries controlled by smallsurface imperfections

Abstract

Navier-Stokes analyses are employed to explore the driving mechanisms controlling asymmetric vortical flows with Re(D) = 0.8 million (Reynolds number based on maximum diameter) over a 3.5 caliber tangent-ogive cylinder at large angles of attack (alpha = 20, 30, and 40 degrees). All flowfield results are steady-state solutions to the three-dimensional, incompressible Navier-Stokes equations in the thin-layer approximation. The numerical results are temporally and spatially fully converged, and are in good agreement with experimental data. The major findings are: (1) for alpha not less than 30 degrees, the vortex flows are genuinely asymmetric yet recurrent; (2) asymmetric vortex patterns are highly sensitive toward such parameters as machine accuracy, grid topology, etc., unless triggered by a slight deformation (similar to an out-of-round nose tip) in the neighborhood of the apex; and (3) for alpha = 20 degrees, the flow is symmetric for both circular and elliptic cross-sectional shapes of the nose tip.