Natural History of Benign Nonimmediate Allergy to Beta-Lactams in Children: A Prospective Study in Retreated Patients After a Positive and a Negative Provocation Test

Abstract

The drug provocation test (DPT) is considered as the gold standard to diagnose drug allergy and is particularly important in the diagnosis of nonimmediate beta-lactam (BL) allergy in children. The natural history of BL allergy remains unknown. Our main aim was to evaluate the natural history of nonimmediate BL hypersensitivity and the long-term tolerance acquisition, and our secondary objective was to determine the negative predictive value (NPV) of the DPT following a 2-day protocol. Children developing a benign rash while treated by BL were prospectively recruited at the Emergency Department of the Geneva University Hospital from 2006 to 2011 and challenged with the incriminated BL (initial diagnostic drug provocation test [idDPT]) following a 2-day protocol. In case of a positive idDPT, the patients underwent a follow-up drug provocation test (fuDPT) 3 years later. In case of a negative idDPT, we sent a questionnaire to assess tolerance of a subsequent treatment with the incriminated BL. Among the 18 children with a positive idDPT, 16 children (89%) had a negative fuDPT and 2 children developed a benign exanthema. Among those 16 children, 11 tolerated a subsequent treatment with the incriminated BL without any reaction, suggesting natural antibiotic tolerance acquisition. From another point of view, we found that the NPV of the DPT following a 2-day protocol was excellent at 96.7%. Our data strongly suggest that a fuDPT is safe and useful to assess tolerance acquisition in children with a confirmed benign nonimmediate BL allergy. In addition, our results support the use of a short DPT protocol (2 days), which led to a high NPV of 96.7% in our population, with a favorable benefit-risk balance.