Multi-taxa marine isoscapes provide insight into large-scale trophic dynamics in the North Pacific

Abstract

Quantifying large scale trophic dynamics and interactions in marine systems remains a key challenge in ecological research and conservation, particularly in remote habitats which are difficult and costly to access. Stable isotope (SI) analysis has emerged as an effective tool for studying ecosystem interactions, especially when used to construct isotopic landscapes, or “isoscapes”. We used a combination of empirical SI data, global modeled phytoplankton isoscapes, and oceanographic data to investigate how large SI datasets might be harnessed to describe and predict patterns of regional food web dynamics and trophic structuring. We collated data from 99 published and author-contributed datasets of carbon and nitrogen SI data for open-ocean and neritic nektonic fish and invertebrates in the North Pacific Ocean to estimate mean SI values for successive trophic level groups within Longhurst biogeographic provinces. We found that these estimates reflected geographic patterns predicted by modeled phytoplankton isoscapes, suggesting that baseline SI ratios are consistently propagated up through regional food webs. This was further corroborated by significant correlations between our estimated SI values with the same oceanographic and geographic variables known to influence phytoplankton SI ratios. However, we observed variable amounts of isotopic offset between successive trophic level groups within and across provinces, indicating that the underlying drivers of trophic dynamics differ across regions. We found evidence of decreased isotopic differences between higher level trophic groups, suggesting the possibility of trophic compression and highlighting the importance of using taxa- and tissue-specific trophic discrimination factors (TDFs) when comparing or predicting consumer SI ratios. We used stable isotopic niche analyses to demonstrate that coupled use of δ13C and δ15N data increased capacity to differentiate province-specific consumer groups, particularly where adjacent provinces had similar ranges of values for a single SI. We also found that baseline isoscapes may be a viable tool for predicting broad trends of consumer SI ratios by calculating ‘predicted’ δ13C and δ15N values for successive trophic groups across provinces using modeled phytoplankton data and diet-dependent discrimination factors. These predicted values were significantly correlated with our estimates based on empirical data, with similarity of predicted δ13C values increasing for higher trophic level groups. We conclude that regional SI patterns remain consistent across diverse ecosystems. With increased spatiotemporal resolution of SI data across ocean basins and increased availability of species-specific life history traits and physiologies, multi-taxa isoscapes hold great potential for studying large scale marine trophodynamics and movement patterns of highly mobile marine species.