Multiresponse problems: desirability and other optimization approaches

Abstract

A diversity of multiresponse optimization methods has been introduced in the literature; however, their performance has not been thoroughly explored, and only a classical desirability‐based criterion has been commonly used. With the aim of contributing to help practitioners in selecting an effective criterion for solving multiresponse optimization problems developed under the response surface methodology framework, and thus to find compromise solutions that are technically and economically more favorable, the working ability of several easy‐to‐use criteria is evaluated and compared with that of a theoretically sound method. Four case studies with different numbers and types of responses are considered. Less‐sophisticated criteria were able to generate solutions similar to those generated by sophisticated methods, even when the objective is to depict the Pareto frontier in problems with conflicting responses. Two easy‐to‐use criteria that require less‐subjective information from the user yielded solutions similar to those of a classical desirability‐based criterion. Preference parameters range and increment impact on optimal solutions were also evaluated.