Multiparametric non-linear TENS modulation to integrate intuitive sensory feedback

Abstract

Objective. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) has been recently introduced in neurorehabilitation and neuroprosthetics as a promising, non-invasive sensory feedback restoration alternative to implantable neurostimulation. Yet, the adopted stimulation paradigms are typically based on single-parameter modulations (e.g. pulse amplitude (PA), pulse-width (PW) or pulse frequency (PF)). They elicit artificial sensations characterized by a low intensity resolution (e.g. few perceived levels), low naturalness and intuitiveness, hindering the acceptance of this technology. To address these issues, we designed novel multiparametric stimulation paradigms, featuring the simultaneous modulation of multiple parameters, and implemented them in real-time tests of performance when exploited as artificial sensory inputs. Approach. We initially investigated the contribution of PW and PF variations to the perceived sensation magnitude through discrimination tests. Then, we designed three multiparametric stimulation paradigms comparing them with a standard PW linear modulation in terms of evoked sensation naturalness and intensity. The most performant paradigms were then implemented in real-time in a Virtual Reality—TENS platform to assess their ability to provide intuitive somatosensory feedback in a functional task. Main results. Our study highlighted a strong negative correlation between perceived naturalness and intensity: less intense sensations are usually deemed as more similar to natural touch. In addition, we observed that PF and PW changes have a different weight on the perceived sensation intensity. As a result, we adapted the activation charge rate (ACR) equation, proposed for implantable neurostimulation to predict the perceived intensity while co-modulating the PF and charge per pulse, to TENS (ACRT). ACRT allowed to design different multiparametric TENS paradigms with the same absolute perceived intensity. Although not reported as more natural, the multiparametric paradigm, based on sinusoidal PF modulation, resulted being more intuitive and subconsciously integrated than the standard linear one. This allowed subjects to achieve a faster and more accurate functional performance. Significance. Our findings suggest that TENS-based, multiparametric neurostimulation, despite not consciously perceived naturally, can provide integrated and more intuitive somatosensory information, as functionally proved. This could be exploited to design novel encoding strategies able to improve the performance of non-invasive sensory feedback technologies.