Multiobjective batch process design aiming at robust performances

Abstract

The most common batch design approach in practice and literature is a deterministic one. However, given the uncertainties prevailing in early stages of process design, a deterministically calculated productivity is not sufficient to select one of the large number of optional designs. Therefore, we propose a Tabu Search multiobjective optimization framework, which allows to approximate the Pareto-optimal set of designs while considering uncertain variables in the initial recipe. As a novel technique, we include performance robustness as a separate objective function within the multiobjective optimization alongside with productivity of a design, thus obtaining not only designs with high productivity or solely robust designs, but both high productivity and robust designs in one set of solutions. We examined several robustness criteria as a possible quantification of performance deviations under uncertain recipe variables. The implementation of a Tabu Search framework in combination with Monte-Carlo simulation and Latin Hypercube sampling provides a huge flexibility in the problem specification, in particular in the definition of parameter uncertainties. As a result we successfully demonstrate that metaheuristic optimization techniques are capable to approximate the Pareto-optimal set under uncertainty and are able to capture potentially antagonistic solution qualities such as high productivity and robustness by multiobjective optimization. With the help of this approach, parameters can be identified that have to be put into the focus of process research and development efforts in order to obtain high performance batch process designs.