Multi-scale analysis of satellite, reanalysis and muti-source precipitation estimates over the Tibetan Plateau

Abstract

Due to the important hydrological and meteorological significance, the performance of different kinds of precipitation products for the Tibetan Plateau (TP) has been evaluated in previous studies. However, the performance of the products on a high spatial-temporal scale has not been clearly shown. Based on the Chinese Meteorological Administration (CMA) ground rain gauge observations during 2017–2018 over the TP, this paper analyzes the multi-scale performance of four satellite-based datasets (IMERG_Uncal, IMERG_Cal, GSMaP_MVK, and GSMaP_Gauge), two reanalysis datasets (ERA5 and ERA5-L), and one multi-source merged dataset (CMFD) for different precipitation intensities with a special attention to the characterization of spatiotemporal variability of heavy precipitation. Firstly, this study examines how the quality of precipitation products varies with time scale and precipitation intensity. CMFD generally shows the best quality and has the most stable quality at all temporal scales. Satellite products perform better in summer while reanalysis products show better results in cold seasons. Another significant issue is the impact of gauge-based calibration. GSMaP_Gauge with daily-scale gauge calibration is often considered to outperform other products. However, our study finds that GSMaP_Gauge is problematic at smaller spatiotemporal scales, especially in capturing heavy precipitation. The long-term performance of multi spatiotemporal scale comparison of different precipitation products is the focus of this study, which can help with their application and improvement.