Morphometric similarity of Mallards and American Black Ducks

Abstract

Morphometric data were collected from 347 American Black Ducks (Anas rubripes), and 1466 Mallards (Anas platyrhynchos) taken by hunters in the Lake St. Clair and Lake Erie regions of southwestern Ontario during autumn 1986 and from 511 American Black Ducks shot throughout the province of New Brunswick during the 1988 and 1989 hunting seasons. Discriminant function analyses based on eight external morphometric variables (wing chord, tarsus length, middle toe length, hind toe length, culmen, head length, naris width, and bill width) did not accurately distinguish Black Ducks from Mallards. Discriminant function analyses produced correct classification rates that, averaged over the four age–sex classes, were 61% for Mallards and 71% for Black Ducks. The highest classification rates were from the discriminant function analyses of Ontario Black Ducks and New Brunswick Black Ducks that, averaged over the four age–sex classes, were 74% for Ontario Black Ducks and 80% for New Brunswick Black Ducks. Although our morphometric analyses did not incorporate all morphometric characteristics of Black Ducks and Mallards, they do show that Black Ducks and Mallards collected in eastern Canada are morphometrically very similar.