Morphological evolution caused by many subtle-effect substitutions in regulatory DNA

Abstract

SummaryMorphology evolves often through changes in developmental genes, but the causal mutations, and their effects, remain largely unknown. The evolution of naked cuticle—rather than trichomes—on larvae of Drosophila sechellia resulted from changes in five transcriptional enhancers of shavenbaby, a gene encoding a transcription factor that governs trichome morphogenesis. Here we show that the function of one of these enhancers evolved through multiple single nucleotide substitutions that altered both the timing and level of shavenbaby expression. The consequences of these nucleotide substitutions on larval morphology were quantified with a novel functional assay. We found that each substitution had a relatively small phenotypic effect, and that many nucleotide changes account for this large morphological difference. In addition, we observed that the substitutions displayed non-additive effects to generate a large phenotypic change. These data provide unprecedented resolution of the phenotypic effects of substitutions and show how individual nucleotide changes in a transcriptional enhancer have caused morphological evolution.