Morphological difference and reproductive isolation: morphometrics in the millipede Parafontaria tonominea and its allied forms

Abstract

Thin-plate spline and other multivariate statistical methods were used to examine the variation in genital morphology and body size in 74 populations of the millipede Parafontaria tonominea and its allied forms in central Japan. Although the study populations included nine sympatric pairs of two reproductively isolated forms, the variations in genital morphology and body size observed were continuous across the study group. Analyses of the sympatric pairs using bootstrapping revealed that the degree of morphological difference between sympatric populations varied considerably from pair to pair. These results demonstrate that the degree of difference in genital morphology and body size may not correspond with the establishment of reproductive isolation. Significant correlation in the pattern of geographic variation was observed for many combinations of morphological components. However, it was not possible to detect a significant correlation between morphology and geographic distance in many of the morphological components studied. This study suggests that the incorporation of genital characters in classification should be done carefully, particularly for animal groups with low vagility, such as millipedes.