Monoculture and mixed-species algal farms on a coral reef are maintained through intensive and extensive management by damselfishes

Abstract

Algal farms maintained by different species of territorial herbivorous damselfishes vary in size, algal biomass, and species composition. To determine the factors that affect the structure of these farms, we compared farming behavior and intensity between two sympatric damselfish species, Stegastes nigricans (Lacepède) and S. obreptus (Whitley), which maintain two different types of farms in the Okinawa Islands, southern Japan. By weeding of indigestible algae and prompt exclusion of herbivorous fishes and grazing sea urchins, S. nigricans manage relatively small farms largely dominated by one algal crop species, Polysiphonia sp. In contrast, by delayed exclusion of herbivores, S. obreptus maintain larger farms invaded by diverse indigestible algae, such as Chondria sp. and Padina sp. As a result of intensive management, S. nigricans attains a higher algal biomass per area than does S. obreptus. This study provides a new perspective, as it suggests that damselfishes practise both intensive and extensive farming. The former results in small and highly productive monoculture farms of one palatable alga, while the latter leads to large, species-rich, mixed-culture farms.