Monitoring metal patterns from urban and agrarian sites using the bumblebee Bombus terrestris as a bioindicator

Abstract

Honeybees are well-established bioindicators for different types of pollutants. This study aims to establish another species of the Apidae family as a bioindicator, with a distinct behaviour and life cycle. The bumblebee Bombus terrestris was used as a bioindicator for 12 metals. Bumblebee hives were placed at sampling sites in and around the city of Aachen, Germany, and metal concentrations were assessed using ICP-MS. Metal concentrations were compared to those found in honeybees described in the literature. Spatial differences in metal patterns were investigated by comparing two land-use types: urban and agrarian. Seasonal differences were compared by taking samples in spring and summer. All analysed metals were detected above the detection limit and within or even above the concentration range found in honeybees. Significant spatial differences were found for the metalloid B and the metal Cd with higher concentrations at the agrarian sites than the urban sites. Significant seasonal differences were found for 8 metals: Fe, Zn, Cu, Ni, Cd, and As concentrations were higher in summer than in spring, while B and V concentrations were higher in spring. To categorise the results, we applied the honeybee contamination index (HCI) and adapted it to bumblebee purposes. According to the HCI, only one agrarian site showed a high contamination level. This study shows that bumblebees are suitable bioindicators for metals. The obtained data can serve as a first baseline in the establishment of additional monitoring studies or risk assessments.