Molecular delimitation methods validate morphologically similar species of red snappers (Perciformes: Lutjanidae).

Abstract

In this study, we tested the taxonomic validation of red snappers species (Southern red snapper Lutjanus purpureus; Silk snapper L. vivanus; Blackfin snapper L. buccanella; and Pacific red snapper L. peru) based on comparative analysis, using four methods for species delimitation. These methods were based on either genetic similarity or phylogenetic trees inferred from two mitochondrial (Cytochrome b and D-loop) and two nuclear (Myostatin and S7 introns) markers. On one hand, the genetic results corroborated the presence of four red snapper species, confirming their taxonomic validation despite their remarkable morphological similarity. On the other hand, few incongruencies in the species delimitation methods were observed according to the phylogenetic reconstruction method (maximum likelihood or Bayesian inference) when using. Based on the phylogenetic results, L. buccanella should represent a more ancient lineage in relation to the clade that encompasses L. purpureus, L. peru and L. vivanus. The single-locus phylogenetic analysis based on Cytb recovered each the red snapper species as a well-supported clade. Overall, this study provided a DNA-based validation of the traditional morphological taxonomy of red snappers.