Molecular characterization of variants of a new ‘rule-breaking’ tobacco rattle virus RNA2 in potatoes

Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) is an important soil-borne virus of potato that is transmitted by stubby-root nematodes. TRV causes corky ringspot, a tuber disease of economic importance to potato production. Utilizing protein-coding regions of the whole genome and a range of computational tools, the genetic diversity, and population structure of TRV isolates from several potato-growing regions (Colorado, Idaho, Indiana, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, and Washington State) in the USA were determined. Phylogenetic analyses based on RNA2 nucleotide sequences, the coat protein (CP) and nematode transmission (2b) genes, showed geographical clustering of USA isolates with previously known American isolates, while European isolates grouped in a distinct cluster. This was corroborated by the observed genetic differentiation and infrequent gene flow between American and European isolates. Low genetic diversity was revealed among American isolates compared to European isolates. Phylogenetic clustering based on RNA1 genes (RdRp, RdRp-RT, and 1a) were all largely incongruent to that of 1b gene (virus suppressor of RNA silencing). This genetic incongruence suggested the influence of recombination. Furthermore, the RdRp, RdRp-RT, and 1a genes were predicted to be more conserved and under negative selection, while the 1b gene was less constrained. Different evolutionary lineages between TRV RNA1 and RNA2 genomic segments were revealed.

Protein extracted from tobacco rattle virus by treatment with formic or acetic acid reassociated in vitro to form rings and tubular structures of indeterminiate lengths in 0.25 molar glycine at pH 7.5 to 9.5. When tobacco rattle virus RNA that had been extracted with phenol was incubated with the protein at 9 degrees C, particles with more regular lengths formed; these particles correspond in size and sedimentation properties to the short particles that normally accompany infection by tobacco rattle virus. The biological activity of the reconstitutted short particles was identical to that of native short particles.

In July 2007, potato tubers cv. Russet Burbank (RB) with necrotic arcs and spots were detected in three fields in Buffalo County, Wisconsin and one field in Benson County, Minnesota. Umatilla Russet (UR) potatoes harvested from the west half of a field in Swift County, MN had similar, but visually distinct necrotic lesions. Portions of one field in Minnesota were abandoned, and the stored potato crop from two fields in Wisconsin was rejected by processors, representing a total crop loss due to tuber necrosis. Tuber symptoms displayed in both cultivars resembled those described for corky ringspot caused by Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) (4). Total RNA was isolated from necrotic tuber tissue crushed in liquid nitrogen and extracted using the Total RNA Isolation Kit (Promega Corp., Madison, WI). These extracts were tested for the presence of TRV by reverse transcription (RT)-PCR using primers complementary to nucleotides 6555 to 6575 and identical to nucleotides 6113 to 6132 within the 3' terminal open reading frame of TRV RNA-1 (3). The expected 463-bp fragments were amplified from RB tubers. Nucleotide sequences from a Wisconsin and Minnesota isolate (GenBank Accession Nos. EU569290 and EU569291, respectively) were 99 to 100% identical to the corresponding region in a published TRV sequence (GenBank Accession No. AF055912). A 396-bp fragment was amplified from UR tubers and sequence data (GenBank Accession No. EU569292) indicated a unique 63 nucleotide sequence was substituted for a 129 nucleotide sequence spanning residues 227 to 357 of the 463-bp amplicon from the RB TRV isolates. Seven fragments were sequenced from different UR tubers and the 396-bp fragment was identical among them. The sequence outside the substituted region had 92% identity to the published TRV sequence. Amplification of the full-length TRV RNA2 using primers 179/180 located in the 5' and 3' untranslated regions (2) was successful for 28 and 0% of the RB and UR samples, respectively, suggesting that the RNA2 is not present in these strains or has undergone significant mutation. TRV-infected sap from both potato cultivars was mechanically transmitted to tobacco cv. Samsun NN and these plants subsequently tested positive for TRV by ELISA using ATCC antiserum PVAS 820. Ninety tubers exhibiting mild to severe symptoms of TRV were planted in the greenhouse. Each tuber was bisected laterally; necrotic tissue was removed from one half of the tuber and tested for the presence of TRV using RT-PCR protocols described above for RNA1. The remaining half was bisected horizontally and both sections were planted. Foliage from each emerged plant was subsequently also tested by RT-PCR for TRV RNA1. All RB tubers from Wisconsin tested positive for TRV, but only 7 of 24 emerged plants tested positive. Only 72% of the UR tubers and 4 of 25 emerged plants tested positive. TRV has been confirmed in California, Colorado, Florida, Idaho, Michigan (1), Oregon, and Washington. To our knowledge, this is the first report of corky ringspot in potato caused by TRV in Minnesota and Wisconsin.

The nucleotide (nt) sequences of two closely related isolates (CeWF-2 and CeWGH-2) of a novel tobacco rattle virus (TRV) RNA2 were determined. The sequences of their RNA2-specific regions were almost identical and contained four open reading frames (ORFs) in an arrangement similar to that found in the previously described TRV TpO1 RNA2. Their predicted ORF 1 gene products shared 97% amino acid sequence identity with the TpO1 coat protein, but the ORF 2 and ORF 3 gene products shared only 82% sequence identity, and no appreciable sequence similarity was found between the CeWF-2/CeWGH-2 and TpO1 ORF 4 gene products. In the CeWGH-2 sequence, the RNA2-specific and RNA1-related regions were separated by seven adenine (A) residues. In CeWF-2, however, an internal poly(A) tract (IPAT) of variable size consisting of ca. 20 to 30 (A) residues was found. This is the first report of an IPAT occurring in a tobravirus RNA2.

Weigela (Weigela florida (Bunge) A. DC., Family: Caprifoliaceae) are woody shrubs native to North China, Korea, and Japan. In the U.S., weigela are commonly used as landscape ornamental plants (McNamara et al. 2010). Two viruses have been reported in weigela: tomato spotted wilt orthotospovirus and impatiens necrotic spot orthotospovirus (Sastry et al. 2019). Ten weigela plants, originating from commercial nurseries in Minnesota, exhibiting chlorosis, chlorotic line patterns, and necrosis (e-Xtra) were submitted for virus diagnostics as potted plants at the University of Minnesota Plant Disease Clinic and the Virology Lab in 2019 and 2020 (five plants each year). Under greenhouse conditions, symptoms progressed from chlorosis to necrosis and even plant death in two of the five plants in 2019. Electron microscopy revealed rod-shaped particles of ≈20 nm in diameter and lengths between 40-200 nm with similar morphology to members of the genus Tobravirus (e-Xtra). Virus-like particles were enriched by ultracentrifugation and total nucleic acids were extracted from partial purifications using a phenol:chloroform extraction method (Lockhart et al. 1997). Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) was identified by cloning and sequencing of the 463bp amplicon obtained with the TRV detection primers described in Robinson, 1992. High-throughput sequencing (HTS) was done to confirm the TRV detection. A cDNA library was prepared from purified viral RNA using the TruSeq Stranded mRNA kit and sequenced on Illumina NovaSeq 6000 platform as 150 bp-paired end reads. A total of 44,316,446 raw data reads were obtained, preprocessed using the BBDuk plugin, and de novo assembled using SPAdes assembler. Viral contigs were identified using the NCBI BLASTX tool. The assembly of TRV RNA1 was 6,842 nt with 20,627,348 reads (47% of total reads) mapped to it and an average coverage per nucleotide at 323,639X. The assembly of TRV RNA2 was 3,033 nt with 22,769,253 reads (52% of total reads) mapped to it and an average coverage per nucleotide at 798,660X. NCBI GenBank accession numbers for the assemblies representing RNA1 and RNA2 are OQ408335 and OQ408336, respectively. NCBI BLASTn analysis showed the highest level of nucleotide identity to TRV genomic RNA segments 1 and 2, with 97% and 99% identity to the TRV isolate RNA1 (GQ903771) and RNA2 (GQ903772), respectively, that originated from Michigan potato. No other viral contigs were detected from the virion nucleic acid extraction by HTS, however this enrichment method doesn't exclude other viruses. In addition to using the detection primers by Robinson 1992, we designed primers based on our HTS data: TRV-WG-DetF3 5'- GACGAAGGAGGCTGTCATTGC-3' and TRV-WG-DetR3 5'-CGGACTATCGTGATGCCCATGC- 3'. RT-PCR amplicons from each of the 10 symptomatic plants were cloned and sequenced. Among these clones, Sanger sequence identities ranged between 96-100% compared to the HTS data and 98-99% to the TRV potato isolate from MI. To our knowledge, this is the first report of TRV infecting the ornamental host W. florida worldwide. TRV is a nematode-transmitted viral pathogen of economic importance, most notably in potatoes (Sastry et al. 2019). In the US, TRV has been reported on several landscape ornamentals, horticultural crops, and native habitats. Further research is needed to investigate the impact of TRV on the ornamental industry and the role of ornamentals as reservoirs for cultivated crops like potatoes.

SUMMARY A near full-length cDNA clone of tobacco rattle virus (TRV) RNA-1 was constructed by joining together nine overlapping cDNA clones using restriction sites in the regions of overlap. At the 5′ end of the cDNA, oligonucleotide mutagenesis was used to insert nucleotides which were missing from the cDNA placing the construct immediately on the 3′ side of the Pr promoter of phage λ to create pTR7116. Extraneous non-viral nucleotides had been deleted from the 3′ end of the TRV cDNA to create a unique SmaI site in pTR7116 in which the nucleotides CCC were provided by the viral cDNA, and GGG by the vector. As a result, pTR7116 could be linearized with SmaI and transcribed in vitro to yield RNA molecules with 5′ and 3′ termini identical to those of natural TRV RNA-1. These transcripts were infectious when inoculated onto leaves of tobacco and produced the subgenomic RNA species typical of an infection with TRV RNA-1.

Mutation and replacement of the 16-kDa protein gene IN RNA-1 of tobacco rattle virus

Functional Replacement of the Tobacco rattle virus Cysteine-rich Protein by Pathogenicity Proteins from Unrelated Plant Viruses

Sixteen isolates of Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) obtained from the United States and Canada were characterized in the present study. Nucleotide-sequence analysis of open reading frame 4 (ORF4) in RNA1 of seven test isolates revealed a high degree of genetic diversity. Potato isolates of TRV clustered in several distinct groups, with isolates from the same geographic region falling into different groups. Phylogenetic analysis of TRV isolates based on nucleotide sequences and on restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) produced similar groupings. TRV was detected in various potato tissues of inoculated, field-grown plants, including progeny tubers, leaves, and roots, by reverse transcription – polymerase chain reaction (RT–PCR), using a pair of TRV-specific primers targeting ORF4. TRV RNA was detected in highly diluted total RNA preparations (1 / 15 625) and in composite tuber samples (200–400 tubers). RT–PCR followed by RFLP analysis was shown to be an efficient procedure for specific and sensitive detection and identification of TRV in potato.

Genome reconstitution and nucleic acid hybridization as methods of identifying particle-deficient isolates of tobacco rattle virus in potato plants with stem-mottle disease

Sedums (Sedum spp.; Crassulaceae) are perennial landscape plants that are grown widely because they are drought tolerant and winter hardy. Plants of Sedum 'Matrona' showing faint foliar ringspot symptoms were collected at a nursery retail outlet in St. Paul, MN in July 2008 and tested for possible viral infection by transmission electron microscopic (TEM) examination of negatively stained, partially purified leaf tissue extracts (1). The only virus-like particles observed were rigid, rod-shaped particles similar to those of Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) and other tobraviruses. A random sample of 100 measurements showed particles 20 nm in diameter with two modal lengths of 115 nm and 175 nm. These virus-like particles were confirmed to be those of TRV by immunosorbent electron microscopy (1) using antiserum to TRV (ATCC PVAS 75) and by reverse transcription (RT)-PCR using total RNA extracted with the RNeasy Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) and primers that yield a 462-bp amplicon from TRV RNA 1 (4). An amplicon of the expected size was obtained by RT-PCR and its nucleotide sequence (GenBank Accession No. GQ268817) had 95 to 99% identity to published TRV sequences (AAW13192 and AAB48382). Two additional amplicons generated by RT-PCR from separate plants were identical in size and nucleotide sequence to the first. On the basis of virion morphology, serological relatedness, and sequence identity, the virus associated with mild ringspot symptoms in sedum was identified as an isolate of TRV. To our knowledge, this represents the first report of TRV incidence in sedum. Although Arabis mosaic virus is the only other virus reported to occur in sedum (2), we have observed numerous, flexuous filamentous 750 to 800 nm virus-like particles in partially purified extracts of a range of sedums showing mild mosaic and/or vein-clearing symptoms in Minnesota. Similar virus-like particles were not observed by TEM in partially purified extracts from TRV-infected 'Matrona' plants, suggesting that they did not contribute to the symptoms observed. We have reported previously (3) the occurrence of TRV in a variety of widely grown perennial ornamentals that provide potential sources of inoculum for spread of this virus by nematode vectors (Trichodorus and Paratrichodorus spp.) that occur commonly in garden soil, and Sedum is now added to the list of potential TRV reservoir plants.

Viral vectors provide a quick and effective way to express exogenous sequences in eukaryotic cells and to engineer eukaryotic genomes through the delivery of CRISPR/Cas components. Here, we present JoinTRV, an improved vector system based on tobacco rattle virus (TRV) that simplifies gene silencing and genome editing logistics. Our system consists of two mini T-DNA vectors from which TRV RNA1 (pLX-TRV1) and an engineered version of TRV RNA2 (pLX-TRV2) are expressed. The two vectors have compatible origins that allow their cotransformation and maintenance into a single Agrobacterium cell, as well as their simultaneous delivery to plants by a one-Agrobacterium/two-vector approach. The JoinTRV vectors are substantially smaller than those of any known TRV vector system, and pLX-TRV2 can be easily customized to express desired sequences by one-step digestion-ligation and homology-based cloning. The system was successfully used in Nicotiana benthamiana for launching TRV infection, for recombinant protein production, as well as for robust virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) of endogenous transcripts using bacterial suspensions at low optical densities. JoinTRV-mediated delivery of single-guide RNAs in a Cas9 transgenic host allowed somatic cell editing efficiencies of ≈90%; editing events were heritable and >50% of the progeny seedlings showed mutations at the targeted loci.

Comparison of the 5'-terminal sequences of several tobraviruses suggests that the RNA-2 molecule of the tobacco rattle virus (TRV) anomalous isolate TCM arose from pea early browning virus (PEBV) RNA-2 by acquisition of 3' and 5' sequences from TRV RNA-1 and RNA-2 molecules, respectively. We have identified a region of homology in the RNA-2 molecules of PEBV, TRV and pepper ringspot virus which could have facilitated this recombination.

Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) isolate PPK20 is transmitted by Paratrichodorus pachydermus nematodes. The factor(s) determining vector transmissibility has been shown to be located on TRV RNA 2. Sequence determination revealed that PPK20 RNA 2 contains three open reading frames encoding the coat protein (cp) and proteins with molecular masses of 29.4 and 32.8 kDa. The 29.4 and 32.8 kDa protein-coding genes showed no significant sequence similarity to any other known tobravirus gene. A full-length cDNA of PPK20 RNA 2 cloned between the 35S promoter and nos terminator infected plants when co-inoculated with PPK20 RNA 1. Deletions in the reading frames of the 29.4 and 32.8 kDa proteins revealed that these sequences are dispensable for replication of PPK20 RNA 2 in plants. Subgenomic RNAs for translation of cp and the putative 29.4 and 32.8 kDa proteins were detected in infected leaves. The possible role of PPK20 RNA 2 non-structural genes in TRV vector transmission is discussed.

Translation of tobacco rattle virus RNA in vitro using wheat germ extracts