Modified Brier score for evaluating prediction accuracy for binary outcomes.

Abstract

The Brier score has been a popular measure of prediction accuracy for binary outcomes. However, it is not straightforward to interpret the Brier score for a prediction model since its value depends on the outcome prevalence. We decompose the Brier score into two components, the mean squares between the estimated and true underlying binary probabilities, and the variance of the binary outcome that is not reflective of the model performance. We then propose to modify the Brier score by removing the variance of the binary outcome, estimated via a general sliding window approach. We show that the new proposed measure is more sensitive for comparing different models through simulation. A standardized performance improvement measure is also proposed based on the new criterion to quantify the improvement of prediction performance. We apply the new measures to the data from the Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium and compare the performance of predicting breast cancer risk using the models with and without its most important predictor.