Mitigation of methane emissions from rice fields: Possible adverse effects of incorporated rice straw

Abstract

Increased world demand for rice production may lead to an increase in methane emission to the atmosphere and future global warming. One suggested way to reduce methane emission is to discourage the practice of incorporating previous crop residue prior to planting rice, since the residue may enhance methane emission from flooded rice fields. This concept is supported by data from a 2‐year study of flooded rice fields on two different soil types in Texas. In 1990, rice stubble from 1989 was incorporated into both soils. Seasonal methane emission from a Lake Charles clay field increased from 15.9 g m−2 in 1989 to 31.0 g m−2 in 1990. In the Beaumont clay field, seasonal methane emission increased from 4.5 to 11.4 g m−2. While methane emission increased between 1989 and 1990, grain yield dropped by 2100 and 840 kg ha−1 in the Lake Charles and Beaumont fields, respectively. Visual inspection at harvest indicated that the 1990 rice yield decrease resulted from grain abortion, presumably caused by the rice cultivar's sensitivity to soil anaerobiosis. The calculated amount of organic carbon not translocated to grain was comparable to the estimated amount of organic carbon required for the increased methane emission. We hypothesize that labile carbon in straighthead susceptible rice cultivars can "leak" from roots damaged by excessively anaerobic soil and be metabolized to its equivalent in methane. These data suggest that minimizing incorporation of crop residue prior to planting can decrease methane emission from flooded rice and reduce the potential for yield loss, particularly with some cultivars and in soils with low rates of seepage and percolation.