Mining the use of higher-order functions:

Abstract

A higher-order function takes one or more functions as inputs or outputs to support the generality of function definitions. In modern programming languages, higher-order functions are designed as a feature to enhance usability and scalability. Abstracting higher-order functions from existing functions decreases the number of similar functions and improves the code reuse. However, due to the complexity, defining and calling higher-order functions are not widely used in practice. In this paper, we investigate the use of higher-order functions in Scala programs. We collected 8,285 higher-order functions from 35 Scala projects in GitHub with the most stars and conducted an exploratory study via answering five research questions of using higher-order functions, including the data scale, the definition types, the definition distribution, the factor that correlates with the function calls, and the developer contribution. Our study mainly shows five empirical results about the common use of higher-order functions in Scala programs. Our findings are listed as follows. (1) Among 35 Scala projects, 6.84% of functions are defined as higher-order functions on average and the average calls per function show that higher-order functions are called more frequently than first-order functions. (2) In all higher-order functions in the study, 87.35% of definitions of higher-order functions and 90.66% of calls belong to the type that only takes functions as parameters. (3) Three measurements (including lines of executable code, Cyclomatic complexity, and warnings in the code style) in higher-order functions are lower than those of first-order functions. (4) Regression analysis on all projects suggests that the number of calling higher-order functions highly correlates with the Cyclomatic complexity. (5) In all projects in the study, 43.82% calls of higher-order functions are written by the same developers who have defined the functions and results show that top 20% authors of higher-order functions favor defining or calling higher-order functions than first-order functions. This study can be viewed as a preliminary result to understand the use of higher-order functions and to motivate further investigation in Scala programs.