Minimally Invasive Robotic Kidney Transplantation for Obese Patients Previously Denied Access to Transplantation

Abstract

Epidemiological data indicate that 20-50% of patients on dialysis for end-stage renal disease (ESRD) are obese (body mass index [BMI] ≥30 kg/m2) (1). Obese patients with chronic renal failure have longer wait times until kidney transplantation (2) and inferior patient outcomes (3-7). In the US, for example, patients with a BMI 40 kg/m2 (2). Higher BMIs in kidney transplant recipients are associated with excess risk of surgical site infections (SSIs), which negatively impact graft survival (8). Obesity is also associated with comorbidities such as diabetes, although data on whether obesity increases mortality in kidney transplanted patients remains unclear (8,9). Provider perceptions of these risks accompanied by the expectation of some centers to give obese patients time to lose weight are the main reasons why a number of transplant centers are reluctant to list obese patients for transplantation (2,10). Unfortunately, many of these obese patients have diabetes and hypertension likely secondary to their obesity (11) and such patients who remain on dialysis have a very high mortality rate. The 5-year mortality rate for diabetic and hypertensive dialysis patients is 75 and 70%, respectively (1). A recent study demonstrated that obese patients who did not present with any SSIs had the same kidney transplant success rate as patients with a normal BMI (8). If surgical procedures could be developed that prevent SSIs and demonstrate successful outcomes, transplant centers may become less reluctant to list obese patients for kidney transplantation. Although any benefit would still have to be weighed against potential increased risks from obesity-related comorbidities. The prevalence of obesity and ESRD is higher among racial and ethnic minority populations, including African-Americans and Hispanics, compared to Non-Hispanic whites (12-15). These observations suggest developing kidney transplantation options for obese patients with ESRD may also help to reduce health disparities in racial and ethnic minorities. We therefore developed a new, minimally invasive, robotic-assisted kidney transplantation method using a short epigastric incision. This method avoids any incision in the infection prone lower quadrants of the abdomen. We hypothesized a priori that the robotic approach would reduce SSIs and improve outcomes in obese kidney transplant patients. Herein, we present our experience and outcomes of the patients undergoing minimal invasive, robotic kidney transplantation at a single institution compared to patients who underwent the conventional open procedure.